Mr Gatti's Pizza

Reviews

• AS

  Anthony Spidale

  4 days ago
  1.0
  Continue your search because I threw this pizza away, went to Walmart and bought pizza dough, cheese, pizza sauce, and pepperoni and made a pizza in 30 mins 100x better and more tasteful than the garbage of which I waited more than 45 mins. This pizza is very gross. Take a cold, dry bite to realize they use the cheapest ingredients available. This place is just not good.
• BS

  Bobby Stevens

  Mar 4, 2026
  2.0
  Every time I’ve come to Mr Gatti’s .I ask for a thin crust ,and they tell me it is and it’s not. It’s like hand toss or something. The other Mr Gatti’s I’ve come to I get thin crust.
• DH

  Deborah Hensley

  Feb 22, 2026
  5.0
  The pizza was perfect to my liking. It was fresh, warm, and very tasty. However, I would’ve liked to have had a little bit more cilantro on the pizza. I will definitely order and try other styles of pizza.
• MG

  Matthew Galvez

  Jan 28, 2026
  1.0
  Service was horrible, this wasn't the first incident. I have tattoos and went to pick up pizza that was under my wife's name and the guy up front asked for the last name (which was fine) but then he comes back with the pizza which was two boxes and proceeded to lie about what kind of pizza was order hoping, I would agree to the "two cheese pizzas" he name and boom he caught me in a lie. But no I corrected him and told him it wasn't two cheese pizzas it was two hamburger meat he then mocked me and slid me the pizza. I should be able to pick up my pizza without the tricks and mind games, and it shouldn't be dry old pizza which was just the cherry on top. Horrible customer service and the pizza was dry!
• AM

  Angelic Martinez

  Dec 3, 2025
  5.0
  Hot, fresh and yummy, what more could you ask for? A school discount, well we got that too. They were very accommodating on Thanksgiving weekend and very easy to work with. We ordered 46 pizzas and needed 2 more when we picked up the order. Guess what, they got us 2 more without issues or complaints or waiting forever for them. If you need good pizzas for a good price without any issues try Mr. Gattis, you won't be disappointed.

Frequently Asked Questions About Mr Gatti's Pizza