Food quality is inconsistent, with some dishes praised while others are criticized for being bland or poorly prepared.
Service Issues
Service is frequently reported as slow and inattentive, with long wait times for food and drinks.
Cleanliness
Several reviews mention cleanliness issues, including dirty tables and restrooms.
Positive Staff Interactions
Some customers highlight excellent service from specific staff members, indicating that service quality can vary.
Atmosphere
The restaurant has a unique and enjoyable atmosphere, though some customers noted it can be too cold or uncomfortable.
NL
nikki livanis
2 days ago
1.0
I came in for an order Togo at the bar. I ordered a shot of Citron while I waited. What came out of the bottle was pure water, so I let the manager know. She tasted it and agreed. I told her to open a new bottle and taste it so she knew I was being honest/serious. She totally agree that what they gave me was water, yet she still charged me for the drink. I told her to keep an eye on her bartenders because they are sipping, stealing and replacing with water. As ab25 year veteran of restaurant management that was very uncool 😎
KS
Katherine Stanford
4 days ago
2.0
First time here, probably not gonna be back. The place wasn’t that clean, tables had hair on them and the floors were covered with dirt and food. The salad was old and slimy, onion rings were greasy, the bacon on the chicken bacon sandwich was old and hard. Really disappointed.
JS
J Stevens
Nov 9, 2025
4.0
Ate dinner there twice this weekend. Chicken fried steak was very good and the boneless porks were good. Sides were OK. I ordered cold slaw once but did not care for it. Fried okra and the dinner salad was very good. The service both nights was excellent.
JS
John S
Nov 8, 2025
5.0
Group of 11 at noon on Saturday. Excellent service. Love the atmosphere.
TB
Tre Berry
Nov 1, 2025
2.0
The service is not the best, the hostesses were not pleasant at all today. They definitely hate their jobs.
I love the fried shrimp there, it’s delicious!!
Frequently Asked Questions About City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar
Do you have vegan or gluten-free options?
We certainly do offer vegan and gluten-free options for our customers with dietary restrictions or preferences.
Will you cater to allergies?
We take allergies very seriously and have measures in place to accommodate them. Our kitchen is set up with separate areas for seafood, meat, and frying to prevent cross-contamination. We also prepare dishes separately for customers with allergies to ensure their safety.
When is your happy hour?
Our happy hour is available daily from 2:00 pm to 5:00 pm, offering special deals and discounts for our patrons.
Do you offer vegan or gluten-free menu options?
Yes, City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar offers vegan and gluten-free options to accommodate dietary preferences and restrictions.
How does City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar handle food allergies?
The cafe has separate kitchen areas for seafood, meat, and frying to avoid cross-contamination and prepares allergy-specific dishes separately to ensure safety.
What are the daily happy hour times at City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar?
Happy hour runs every day from 2:00 pm to 5:00 pm featuring special deals and discounts.
What are the regular opening hours of City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar?
The cafe is open from 10:30 am to 8:00 pm Monday through Friday and Sunday, and until 9:00 pm on Saturdays.
Does City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar offer pickup and delivery services?
Yes, the cafe provides in-store pickup, curbside pickup, and delivery services for customer convenience.
What payment methods are accepted at City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar?
They accept American Express, Apple Pay, Cash, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa.
Can you tell me about nearby attractions to visit before or after dining at City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar?
After your meal, you can explore The George Washington Rogers House, a nearby historical museum and landmark worth visiting.
Are there any nearby auto-related services close to City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar if I need vehicle assistance?
Yes, WC Auto Center and W.C. Auto Center are nearby for automotive repairs and tire services, convenient if you need car maintenance before or after your visit.
Where can I find local insurance agencies near City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar?
There are multiple insurance agencies nearby including Freeway Insurance, The Chris Batten Agency, and Nationwide Insurance: Christopher Lawrence Batten for your insurance needs.
Is catering available at City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar for special events?
Yes, City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar offers catering services to accommodate your events and gatherings.