Mr Gatti's Pizza

Reviews

• AG

  Alicia Garza

  Apr 18, 2026
  5.0
  We planned my son’s birthday last minute and couldn’t find any openings, but Mr. Gatti's Pizza came through! Ms. Terri helped us book a party the same day and made everything easy. Great customer service, clean place, and fun games. My son had a great birthday we’ll definitely be back!
• PT

  Price Tm

  Apr 16, 2026
  3.0
  Over priced. Not the best not the worst very chewie not enough enough meat very small hamburger .first time customer and last time customer not going back. A waist of money.
• JM

  Jerry Miller

  Apr 15, 2026
  5.0
  Big Mr.Gattis with lots of games and room to sit. Clean and the food was good. Salad bar was awesome.
• IS

  IT’S ALWAYS SUMTHIN

  Apr 9, 2026
  5.0
  Never been here until today and I’m so glad we did! Came on a Thursday and a parent eats FREE, there are specials everyday, plus we signed up for messages and got a FREE game card, my first time impression was Megann and she gave the BEST customer service a girl could ask for! CLEAN atmosphere all around, the Parmesan shaker had herbs infused, Huge tv my son watched while he ate and as I write this we haven’t even gotten to the games yet and we already are having fun, check it out!
• JD

  Jamas Dinial

  Mar 19, 2026
  3.0
  Disappointed is all I can use to describe our visit. As a life long resident in Oklahoma. The Mr. Gatti's in okc is top shelf and top notch dinning. Since moving here to Dallas in late 2024 im just now discovering this location on Mcarty. We went with real knowledge of how this place should be. Okc is like I said top notch from the incredible variety of items on the bar to the freshness of the items with exceptional cleanliness. The pizza dough there once cooked actually melts in your mouth. Baked potatoes brownies and cookies are all on the bar as well. The place looks nice but the food was frightening. Salad bar was a mess. Labels for dressings were un readable. Every and i mean every pizza tasted hot something spicy and hott in the sauce ruined the taste. Hand tossed dough crust was like card board. Horrible. I requested a thin crust pizza made which was a little better but still to spicy especially for children. Some running this place has altered recipes. Spinach pizza had way too much thick spinach on it. Like eating seaweed horrible. Hard stale cinnamon sticks and cherry straddle only two deserts for 14 dollars?? Come on. Who has ran this place into the ground. All manager staff should be fired and replaced by folks in okc who could show you guys what this place should be like. Cashier said this location on mcarty is supposedly considered the best??? Omg. What an embarrassing failure this place is. Seriously get in touch with the location on Britton and May Ave. In Oklahoma City. They can teach this place how to do it properly. Im embarrassed to have told people to go try it because of past okc experiences. I hope corporate sees this plea for helping this horrible location. We are long time customers from the 80s. What in the world has happened here. Please get newly trained staff and change management for the Gattis name sake and reputation of a quality pizza place. Good luck.