West by God CoalFired Pizza

Reviews

• SK

  steve Kibler

  1 day ago
  1.0
  We stopped in here on a Sunday afternoon in January 2026. We think the pizza here at West By God is the best in Pigeon Forge. We have been here many times in the past. On this day however the service was absolutely horrible. We sat for a while watching some people get up and leave because they did not get waited on. The place was busy with only one server that I could see at the time and she was behind the bar most of the time. The hostess who was very nice finally asked us for our drinks order and she returned with our drinks. After about 20 minutes or so the server finally took our pizza order we ordered two pizzas because in the past they are so good. Well about 30 more minutes went by we asked the hostess if she could check on our pizza order and she did. She returned and said it would be about 15 more minutes before our pizza would be out. Well by this time I knew the server probably forgot to put our order in. The nice thing about this pizza restaurant is it doesn’t take long to cook a pizza so that is how we knew our order was not put in. So we have been sitting for over an hour so we told the hostess to give us the bill for our drinks tea and a coke and we would go somewhere else to eat. I have heard of a lot of other people saying the service is bad here well this was the first time we experienced bad service. We hope it will get better here soon. Unfortunately we probably will not be back here for pizza. We live here and there are just too many restaurants to eat at here in the Pigeon Forge area.
• RB

  roger bailey

  3 days ago
  5.0
  West By God Pizza absolutely deserves 5 stars! The pizza and hot wings combo in the photo says it all – perfectly cooked to order, with a crispy, flavorful crust, plenty of toppings, and wings that came out hot, juicy, and full of flavor. The staff were friendly from the moment I walked in, checked on me several times, and made sure everything was just the way I wanted it. If you’re looking for great pizza, awesome wings, and welcoming service, West By God Pizza is a must-visit.
• MK

  Melinda Koller

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Love Love Love!! Best pizza and pretzel with beer cheese!! Will definitely be our go to place when we’re back in P.F.awesome staff and cool vibe including the beer wall.
• CO

  Coleen Owens

  Feb 5, 2026
  5.0
  Singo and 1/2 priced pizza on Thursday! We had a blast! Table for 13 please!! Food was Great! Server did a Great job! Had a Great time! Will be back! Some of our group did the Axe throwing also! It was all fun! Great atmosphere!
• JP

  Jen P

  Jan 24, 2026
  5.0
  No photos of the pizza or the pizza rolls but dang, they were amazing. After hearing about the coal fired pizza from the locals, I just knew this needed to be checked out. We ordered the Boggy Bomb which has pepperoni and sausage with bacon jam. Had the bacon jam on the side as I want so sure if I’d like it. I’ll just say it was amazing. Lots of bacon flavor with a hint of heat. Definitely have it on the next time. The pizza rolls were extremely tasty and the marinara dipping sauce was some of the tastiest I’ve had since moving from NH. And the beer wall was really cool. I’ll definitely be back.

Frequently Asked Questions About West by God CoalFired Pizza