Slice Midtown

Reviews

• EG

  Emma Gant

  2 days ago
  5.0
  Everything was amazing! Only complaint is that the salad and cannolis that were supposed to come with the Pasto Completo were missing, but that’s partially my fault for not checking my to go order before I left. We’ll definitely be back!
• SP

  Steve Parker

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Very good pizza. Fast service.
• TC

  Trevor Cotton

  Feb 22, 2026
  3.0
  This was our first visit and we decided to dine in. This was a Saturday evening but the dining room was empty apart from the son of one of the employees who was quietly playing at one of the tables. Christmas decorations, an old TV and some furniture was stacked up at one end of the room, and some Christmas decorations were still on the wall. The waitress was very pleasant and quickly took our order. My wife ordered a pepperoni Stromboli and I ordered a deluxe pizza. An accident in the kitchen meant my pizza had to be remade, but I was given some free garlic knots to eat while I waited, which were appreciated. My wife said her Stromboli had plenty of cheese and pepperoni and tasted very good. A minor observation was that some of the cheese had not melted although the outside was fully cooked. The knots came with plenty of cheese and garlic and tasted good. When my pizza arrived it was, unfortunately, still soggy in the center and the cheese was not all melted. I had to go to the counter to request some silverware to eat it with. The pizza had a decent amount of toppings that tasted good and fresh. Very soon after I received the pizza we were given the bill. If it was me serving, I would wait until the customer had finished and then ask if they wanted a desert - missed opportunity there. Overall, the food tasted good but we did not enjoy the dine in experience at all. They seemed to have a decent amount of customers picking up togo orders while we were there, so we will likely go that route if we go again, even though we generally don’t like that type of restaurant dining.
• ES

  Eddie Seratt

  Feb 22, 2026
  5.0
  This order was take-out. Prior orders were in the restaurant. Each order has been delicious. We like it, our kids and grandkids like it. Service is efficient and friendly. What more can you want?
• BB

  Ben

  Feb 9, 2026
  5.0
  Great food! We've tried a lot of their offerings (sample box) and they don't make just good pizza, they've got a lot of other great items. Happy to have them in Brunswick! Oh and they've got great prices, much more reasonable than other local pizza spots.

Frequently Asked Questions About Slice Midtown