At Papa Johns Pizza in York, SC, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best York pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in York or stop by 914 E.Liberty St for carryout to order the best pizza in York, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Customers frequently reported long wait times, incorrect orders, and issues with delivery services.
Food Quality
Many reviews mentioned undercooked or poorly prepared pizzas, with complaints about toppings and overall quality.
Customer Service
Several customers experienced rude or unprofessional behavior from staff, particularly from management.
Positive Staff Feedback
Despite negative experiences, some customers praised individual staff members for their friendliness and good service.
Inconsistent Experience
Overall, customer experiences varied widely, with some enjoying their meals while others expressed significant dissatisfaction.
CR
cindy robinson
Feb 14, 2026
3.0
I ordered my pizza off of their website and it switch to door dash delivery. What ended up happening was me waiting, them canceling my order and stealing my food. The manager was nice though, I drove up and got the pizza free. I hope they needed it bad enough ..must have been starving or the pizza must have been GLORIOUS . Idk but I don't think I'd be doing delivery anymore
BB
Bobby
Feb 8, 2026
5.0
Ordered 2 pizzas for Super Bowl Sunday. Food arrived before the estimated delivery time. Delivery driver was great, food was hot and delicious. Thank you.
MM
MJefe
Jan 24, 2026
1.0
Everyone is nice there except the red head/beareded guy always in a bad mood and has an attitude .
MD
Matthew Durden
Jan 17, 2026
1.0
Stay far away
Order kept cancelling and thought was a glitch on this end but after third try or so
Get a nasty ring from Papa John's saying very rudely to quit ordering or they would get the police on the horn
And yes other reviews are correct also
Undercooked pizza and extra long wait times
Would help to have employees
Been times only one person running the entire restaurant