At Papa Johns Pizza in Sumter, SC, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Sumter pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Sumter or stop by 435 N GUIGNARD DR for carryout to order the best pizza in Sumter, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Customers had mixed experiences with food quality, with some praising the pizza as delicious while others reported issues like dry crust, incorrect toppings, and undercooked items.
Service Issues
Numerous reviews highlighted poor customer service, including incorrect orders, long wait times, and unprofessional staff behavior.
Delivery Problems
Many customers experienced issues with delivery, such as delays, missing items, and reliance on third-party services like DoorDash.
Positive Experiences
Despite the negatives, several customers praised the overall quality of the pizza and the efficiency of the staff during busy times.
RH
Rose Howard
Jan 3, 2026
3.0
Imagine ordering a new york style crust and was given thin crust. Very damn disappointed! ☹️☹️☹️
TG
Ty Grant
Dec 21, 2025
5.0
Food was good
TE
Thelita Evans
Dec 14, 2025
5.0
Everything was excellent
TC
Terrie Coyote
Dec 7, 2025
1.0
Dry as a bone. Almost card board. Tasted like pizza Hut. Maybe because I bought the 9.99 deal. Thin crust. Hardly any sauce at all. No mushrooms and I ordered them. I'm very disappointed. I haven't had Papa John's in years. Now I remember y.
JF
Jennifer Fretwell
Dec 2, 2025
5.0
The new York style pizza is the closest thing I've had to ny pizza anywhere!