Pizza Inn

3.9
1421 reviews

About

Restaurant
America's Hometown Pizza Place™ since 1958. Home of the Original Thin and Original Pizza Buffet. Pizzas are hand-made daily with fresh dough. Choose from a variety of pizzas, pasta, salad, and desserts!

Location

Pizza Inn
1404 Church Street, Conway, SC
29526, United States

Hours

Reviews

3.9
1,421 reviews
5 stars
707
4 stars
303
3 stars
164
2 stars
83
1 star
164

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Food Quality

Mixed reviews on pizza quality; some found it acceptable while others described it as cardboard-like or cold.

Service Issues

Frequent complaints about slow service, unprofessional behavior from staff, and difficulty getting attention from waitstaff.

Cleanliness

Multiple reports of unsanitary conditions, particularly in the bathrooms and buffet area.

Buffet Experience

The buffet is appreciated for variety and affordability, but often criticized for being poorly stocked and not well-maintained.

Positive Staff Interactions

Some customers praised specific staff members for their friendliness and helpfulness, indicating that service can vary.
  • JB
    Jason Benke
    1 day ago
    5.0
    Pizza is good, especially fresh, not like, your new favorite pizza, however, for the price? Excellent, and the best part about this place? The staff, they are excellent, quick refills, kind faces
  • LG
    Liz G
    Jan 2, 2026
    5.0
    Huge variety of pizzas on the buffet including taco pizza and cheeseburger pizza. They also have pasta, garlic bread,salad and dessert pizzas on the buffet
  • MM
    Mike McCale
    Dec 26, 2025
    5.0
    Good salad bar.
  • TT
    TheMunchcw
    Dec 20, 2025
    5.0
    They're buffet is great especially you get to tell them what pizza you want on the buffet salad bar and dessert pizza is busting
  • SS
    SouthernRock10
    Nov 30, 2025
    5.0
    Was curious about the reviews for this place and surprised it was only at 3.9, which from what I've read is mostly people that are from out of town that have had their taste buds burned off with the copious amounts of cigarettes they put out on their tongue and prefers cardboard style thin pizza. Have been going to this location since I was six so nostalgia might play a part in the review. Growing up we would always go to the buffet, which isn't a bad option, but they tend to make more thin style pizza, which I believe anyone who likes this style of pizza just enjoys being miserable. If you're a person who actually enjoys life and pizza then I'm going to tell you the only true option is to order the house pan pizza of any kind you like, which you can never go wrong with the cheeseburger pizza. We usually order this to go right around the afternoon when they are not so busy on the weekday or close to when they open on the weekend, just not Sundays, because it gets fairly busy with the church crowds. Id recommend takeout because I'm a recluse and enjoy the sweet sounds of silence and not having to wait for Dorthey to figure out if she wants to get the pepperoni or taco pizza. If you decide you like the buffet option to take the family you can still request any style crusted pizza but they will give you a few slices and place the rest at the bar. Cant say anything about the salad bar because I'm not a rabbit and who really goes to a pizza place for that... like come on.. you are one of those chicken tender at a steak house kind of person. Apparently they have good spaghetti but again pizza place. The deserts are top tier with the chocolate chip pizza being I think the best option for the whole family. The only bad things I can say is yes the bathrooms are small and probably needs a bit of remodeling. The fact they got rid of the old mortal combat arcade game and the small baseball pinball machine to win a rubber ball saddens me if I ever have to walk in. And the last thing is I think its under new management because I don't see the original manager in the past few years because since he left the only pizza that isn't cooked the way it suppose to be is the barvarian cream pizza desert. Its always to runny and dripping off the crust when you get it. It use to be more solid. All I can say is this place definitely beats pizza hut, dominoes, and even Anto's pizza

Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza Inn

What type of food does Pizza Inn serve?

Pizza Inn serves a variety of pizzas, pasta, salad, and desserts, featuring hand-made pizzas with fresh dough daily.

What are the operating hours for Pizza Inn in Conway?

Pizza Inn is open from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.