Cosmic Pizza Steak & Wieners

Reviews

• ML

  Meghan Love

  Dec 31, 2025
  5.0
  This is by far my favorite pizza place EVER! Best taste, best customer service, and always friendly!
• JH

  Jake Harvey

  Dec 30, 2025
  2.0
  Cosmic has been awesome for years but something has changed lately and they are objectively worse. If you order a BLT, be sure to tell them that they actually have to cook the bacon. We got two BLTs and on each one, about half of the bacon was not sufficiently cooked (see image). The workers are always friendly. I don't know what is different, but clearly something is.
• DF

  Denise Ford

  Dec 17, 2025
  5.0
  Every time I have had something from here it’s always delicious and authentic. Never disappointed. Highly recommended.
• TC

  Timothy Chace

  Dec 2, 2025
  4.0
  Fifth stop for the day. Second of the final three on today's RI FOOD FIGHTS Lord of the Pies run. Six pizzas total. By this point you start questioning your life choices, but then you walk into a place like Cosmic Pizza Steak & Weiners and remember why you're doing this. Cosmic Pizza was home base for Pilgrim High School kids back in the '80s. The place we'd hit after basketball and hockey games, when pizza was fuel and community was guaranteed. Walking in tonight felt like stepping into a time machine, except everything's been upgraded. The location moved down the street from the original spot. Cleaner now. More modern. Brighter. The kind of place that kept what mattered and improved everything else. And the pizza? Better than it was back then. The place was packed. Standing room only with about fifteen people waiting for orders despite the ovens running full tilt. Tables full, to go orders flying out the door. A neighborhood spot that's clearly still doing what it's always done, just evolved. Rob, the manager, runs the room like he's conducting an orchestra in the middle of a rush. The place is buzzing, hectic, absolutely humming with activity, but he's got it all under control. And somehow, in the middle of all that, he still takes the time to talk to you. Makes it clear how grateful he is that you showed up. That's not just good service. That's genuine hospitality under pressure. The pizza justifies the crowd. The crust is what stands out first. Super light, airy, crispy in a way that feels almost delicate but still has structure. Not thin crust territory but not thick either. Just right for what they're doing. The sauce brings herbs forward. Savory, not sweet. You can taste the seasoning, taste the intent behind it. The cheese is quality stuff, melts right, browns in the spots that matter. Whatever toppings you order are going to be good because they're clearly not cutting corners on ingredients. The operation itself is something to watch. Tons of people working, all moving fast, all under pressure. But every single one of them smiles. Acknowledges you. Makes it clear they're grateful you showed up. That's culture, not accident. That comes from the top down through Rob to everyone on the line. Nostalgia can mess with your judgment. Makes you think things were better than they were. But Cosmic proves you can go back and find something actually improved. The energy is the same. The community feel is the same. Everything else got better. The space, the food, the friendliness of everyone involved. Fifth pizza of the day, stomach protesting, and this one lands differently because of what it represents. A place that's been feeding a community for decades and somehow got better instead of coasting on history. Worth the wait. Worth the crowd. Worth coming back when you're not trying to eat six pizzas in one day. And we will. 💪❤️🍕
• JD

  Johnny D

  Dec 1, 2025
  3.0
  Ordered from here through Uber Eats this afternoon. Ordered 8 wieners and a large fry. All the weiners were packed into the same bag on top of each other. The ones in the picture were actually on top inside the bag. The bottom 3 were pretty squished. I guess that's no different than most other places, but they could still do it better than the rest. Taste wise they were fine. Not as good as NYS, but the price is definitely better. The fries had no salt on them, which would be fine if they included salt packets and maybe ketchup. I checked the box to include disposables and left a note in the app asking for both napkins and vinegar packets. I did not get either. I wasn't aware the fries would not come with salt, or I would have asked for that as well. I wouldn't have gotten any apparently, but I would have asked lol Now you know at least.

Frequently Asked Questions About Cosmic Pizza Steak & Wieners