Sicilia's Pizzeria

Reviews

• JH

  James Hill

  1 day ago
  5.0
  Sicilia's is a truly unique and delicious experience, that is worthy of any who enjoy an adventurous pizza experience. The Stuffed Pizza is an excellent blend of genuine Sicilian style at its core, with its focus on a sweet yet tangy sauce over an airy dough base, and deep dish, with a tall crust that allows that airy dough to crisp incredibly nicely around the entirety of the pie. The stretch of the mozzarella that comes from having it practically boiled underneath the sauce is astounding, keeping it extremely moist and springy. This made our server's clearly practiced skill in serving our first slices particularly impressive, as well as making it a memorable experience when we attempted to recreate the motion to varying degrees of success as we subsequently served our seconds. On top of being exceptionally helpful, personable, and attentive throughout the meal, and guiding us through the menu while ensuring we had what we needed, the server even stepped in to teach us the technique, which is above and beyond. The restaurant itself is simple in with a very classic Italian-American motif, creating a familiar, comforting, and welcoming space that suits the expectation. The slight smokiness in the air from the oven as the smell wafts through the entire length of the restaurant is captivating, and all areas I saw were sufficiently clean as well, which is always an excellent sign. The food and atmosphere compliment one another ideally. This is easily one of the best pizzas I have ever had, and I look forward to having again next time I visit.
• KN

  Kelly Nevins

  6 days ago
  4.0
  We’re from Chicago and Sicilia’s thin crust is like a taste of home. Tonight’s pizza delivery arrived hot and cheesy…unfortunately, the cheese had slid to one side during delivery. It was still tasty!
• KT

  K Tate

  Feb 20, 2026
  5.0
  The deep dish pizza was delicious and still warm when it was delivered. Too much food. But I will be in heaven for several days with leftovers.
• SK

  Stephanie Krause

  Feb 14, 2026
  5.0
  Out of towner here... took a chance on a place we didnt know on Valentine's Day. Timely and friendly delivery, pizza still hot! Antipasto amd tiramisu were delish!
• PS

  patel shashwat

  Feb 10, 2026
  5.0
  This place is out of this world! 😍🤩🔥 have been coming to this place since long time 😀. The things I love about this place are they are famous for deep dish pizza, calamari, sphagetti w meatballs and they are open late night so perfect place to stop by at night or do some “me” time in the restaurant alone. 😎