Customers frequently praised the pizza, especially the stuffed and deep dish varieties, noting them as some of the best they've ever had.
Service
While many reviews highlighted friendly and attentive service, there were notable complaints about rude staff and poor customer service experiences.
Delivery Issues
Several customers reported long wait times and issues with delivery, including incorrect orders and poor communication.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as clean and welcoming, with a pleasant atmosphere for dining.
Pricing Concerns
Some customers felt the prices were high, especially with added fees, leading to mixed feelings about value for money.
MM
Macy
Nov 22, 2025
5.0
Came for the first time from RI food fights and can we just say we were absolutely blown away by this place. The staff was so friendly, and the freaking PIZZA! phenomenal. We never would have thought to come here because we aren’t big fans of Federal Hill (we hate dealing with parking) but we absolutely will be coming back because it was totally worth it. Best pizza ever. 10/10 on everything!
BW
brookes wittkamper
Nov 19, 2025
5.0
From Chicago, finally found pizza I love in RI. The stuffed pizza is delicious with a light buttery crust. It’s a close contender to the deep dish pizza I know and love. The staff is wonderful.
RC
Roger Clemons
Nov 6, 2025
1.0
Place looked nice but was really disappointed by the food itself, looked like promising deep dish from what I’ve seen online but just got this slop that looks hours old… took one bite and threw it out.
KR
Kevin Rodriguez
Nov 2, 2025
5.0
Best pizza in the area, the staff and drivers are always so nice, they even come to my door sometimes and I live in a big building. I love this place
SS
S281Emustang
Oct 28, 2025
4.0
Ordered an XL thin crust cheese for delivery less than a mile away. I was told 30-35 minutes. Pizza was delivered in about an hour. I understand complications can arrise. The pizza itself was exactly what i expected, it was great. The crust was very flakey and buttery. I wish i sprung for a deepdish but didnt have the appetite for it at the time. I would order from here should i ever be in the area again.
Frequently Asked Questions About Sicilia's Pizzeria
What are the operating hours for Sicilia's Pizzeria?
Sicilia's Pizzeria is open daily from 10:00 AM. On Monday through Thursday and Sunday, it closes at 2:00 AM. On Friday and Saturday, it closes at 3:00 AM.
Does Sicilia's Pizzeria offer delivery and in-store pickup services?
Yes, Sicilia's Pizzeria offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
Where is Sicilia's Pizzeria located?
Sicilia's Pizzeria is located at 181 Atwells Ave, Providence, RI, 02903, USA.
What types of food categories does Sicilia's Pizzeria specialize in?
Sicilia's Pizzeria specializes in pizza, Italian cuisine, sandwiches, seafood, pasta, salads, gluten-free options, desserts, and also offers catering services.
What is the price range at Sicilia's Pizzeria?
The price range at Sicilia's Pizzeria is moderate, categorized as 'Two'.
Where can I view the menu or place an order online?
You can view the menu and place orders online at https://siciliasonline.com/menu.
Can you name some nearby Italian restaurants to Sicilia's Pizzeria?
Nearby Italian restaurants include Cassarino's Restaurant and Andino's Restaurant, both great options if you're exploring Italian cuisine in the area.
What nearby landmarks or attractions can I visit before or after dining at Sicilia's Pizzeria?
You can visit Atwells Avenue, a local landmark and historical building nearby, which is perfect for a stroll before or after your meal.
Are there other lounges or bars near Sicilia's Pizzeria where I can enjoy a drink?
Yes, nearby lounges and bars include City Hall Cigar Bar, INSA Lounge, and Afrique D' Lounge, offering great places to relax and enjoy a drink.
How can I contact Sicilia's Pizzeria for reservations or inquiries?
You can contact Sicilia's Pizzeria by calling +1 401-273-9222.