Many customers reported poor service, including long wait times, unresponsive staff, and mistakes with orders.
Food Quality
While some customers enjoyed the food, there were numerous complaints about cold, overcooked, or incorrect items.
Pricing Concerns
Several reviews mentioned that the prices were too high for the quality of food received.
Positive Staff Interactions
Despite the service issues, some customers praised specific staff members for their friendliness and attentiveness.
TC
Tenley Cassidy
2 days ago
5.0
Chris provides excellent service!! We had a large party and he was awesome 😎 Very much appreciated and thanks again!
FF
Franzankenfranz
Dec 17, 2025
1.0
Got a food poison from that chicken👎👎
AM
Ahmed Mohamed
Dec 10, 2025
3.0
They refused to make my order 40 minutes before closing the kitchen was closed 😒
MF
Michael Feigum
Dec 2, 2025
4.0
The sampler was excellent. The variety and flavors were very good. The hatch chili queso is my favorite. Unfortunately service fell below standards. The server had no personality and didn't have a smile. Only as we were ready to pay the bill did she ask if we want any refills. Our glasses sat empty for a little while. The atmosphere was good.
JJ
Jess
Nov 27, 2025
2.0
My boyfriend and I ordered takeout on 10/23 and when he went to go pick it up, they said they did not have anymore of the potato wedges available and the cashier said she would go look to see what they had made up that they could replace it with. My boyfriend waited about 5-7 minutes when she finally came back out with her manager and said “oh so you want a refund” and he was like okay i guess? so she said okay it’ll take about 3-5 days for the refund to go back to your card. so then when he finally came home, we go to eat and i’m missing my french fries that came with my meal. 2 things now gone from our order so i call them and said to refund the french fries as well and there’s no apology, she just says it will be a few days before the refund goes back to our account.
It gets to 11/03 so two weeks go by and still no refund. i call them that night just to see if there was an update. i get transferred to a manager and she said oh they took the potato wedges off the bill and i said uh no unfortunately they did not, we still paid the full $51.36 of our order and she tried to argue that and i said no we got fully charged. she said she will have to send this to her district manager and it will take a few days. i say okay.
it is now 11/27, another 2 weeks and STILL no refund. and we also have never gotten an apology.
i swear every SINGLE time we get take out from here, it is either incorrect or something is missing. Absolutely ridiculous and unprofessional.
Still waiting on that refund.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in Williamsport offer?
Buffalo Wild Wings in Williamsport offers award-winning Buffalo-style wings with a choice of 26 sauces and seasonings.
What are the operating hours of Buffalo Wild Wings in Williamsport?
Buffalo Wild Wings is open Monday to Thursday from 11:00 AM to midnight, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 1:00 AM, and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in Williamsport?
Buffalo Wild Wings is located at 25 Liberty Lane, Williamsport, PA 17701, USA.
Is Buffalo Wild Wings in Williamsport a dine-in or takeout restaurant?
Buffalo Wild Wings in Williamsport operates as a chicken wings restaurant, sports bar, and takeout restaurant.
How can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Williamsport?
You can contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Williamsport by calling +1 570-321-5613.
Does Buffalo Wild Wings have an online presence where I can learn more or place orders?
Yes, Buffalo Wild Wings has a website for the Williamsport location: https://www.buffalowildwings.com/locations/us/pa/williamsport/25-liberty-lane/sports-bar-927/
What nearby restaurants can I visit before or after dining at Buffalo Wild Wings?
Nearby restaurants include Golden Strip, Denny's, The Crazy Tomato, Popeyes® Louisiana Kitchen, Arby's, Qdoba, Five Guys, McDonald's, and Bruster's Real Ice Cream.
Are there hotels close to Buffalo Wild Wings in Williamsport for overnight stays?
Yes, nearby hotels include Hampton Inn & Suites Williamsport-Faxon Exit and Hampton by Hilton, both conveniently located for visitors.
Where can I find automotive services near Buffalo Wild Wings in Williamsport?
Automotive services near Buffalo Wild Wings include The Car Wash at Faxon and Tire Choice Auto Service Centers.
Can I find financial services near Buffalo Wild Wings in Williamsport?
Yes, nearby financial services include Northwest Bank, The Comprehensive Financial Group, OneMain Financial, and Roche Financial, Inc.