Numerous customers reported slow service, with long wait times for food and drinks, and servers being inattentive or unresponsive.
Food Quality
Many reviews highlighted poor food quality, including cold dishes, incorrect orders, and overall dissatisfaction with the taste and presentation of meals.
Positive Staff Interactions
Despite the issues, some customers praised specific staff members for their friendliness and attentiveness, indicating that service quality can vary.
Atmosphere and Experience
The restaurant's atmosphere was generally appreciated, with many noting it as a good place to watch sports, although some found it too loud.
JJ
Jftravels
3 days ago
5.0
Buffalo Wild Wings in West Mifflin is a classic sports bar and grill located near the Century III Mall area. It is a popular destination for locals to watch games, eat some good food and good drinks. They offer a high energy environment with numerous large screen televisions and a wide selection of draft beers. The food here is delicious and the service was great..
DA
Dennis Anderson
6 days ago
1.0
6 single wing pieces.
Dry and small
4 flats..2 drums
$1.65 each piece
HIGHWAY ROBBERY
Never..Never..Again eating there........
AS
Autumn Sprys
Dec 18, 2025
1.0
Servers don’t even realize half the table didn’t get the food. So server gets them and delivers them COLD or not at all! Service super slow. I wouldn’t go here. Go to North Fayette location
JJ
Jash Jasani
Dec 12, 2025
2.0
I was picking up an online order at Westminister location ready-by certain time, checked with cashier she said it's not ready and replied no worries I can wait. Checked back after 15 min, same response no status update like half is ready or something along the lines. I literally had to call back after 5-10 min and the cashier didn't even pick up the phone some guy from the kitchen did, coz he was not able to figure out order status. THIS IS NOW STRAIGHT UP CARELESS AND UNPROFESSIONAL!!
I am not sure if the store manager knows there are LOT more cashiers/servers than people in kitchen.
Another thing is the mobile app is USELESS that show no status about order or even basic one "Hey your order is ready for pick up"
MG
Mr. Happy Go-Lucky
Dec 7, 2025
1.0
I rarely come to BWW anymore because the wings are overpriced and a complete disappointment. I decided to go the other day to see if anything has improved and it has not. Ordered 10 wings for $15.49, what a rip off. My wings came out almost cold like they have been sitting under a heat lamp for an hour or were just microwaved for 15 seconds and sauce just slathered on. The wing quality itself was horrible. Small wings, mediocre amount of meat. The meat was so tough it actually made my jaw sore to chew. Had one deformed wing in there, of course where the bone broke in half which was gross. I ate them because I was hungry. I didn't want to complain because the bartender was really busy. I will never come here again. Literally anywhere else has better wings. The bartender was very nice though. So that's good. But overall this company serves sub-par food that is overpriced and sloppily made in the back by whoever they can get to work there. What an absolute disappointment.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What types of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in West Mifflin specialize in?
Buffalo Wild Wings offers award-winning Buffalo, New York-style wings with your choice of 26 sauces and seasonings.
What are the operating hours of Buffalo Wild Wings in West Mifflin?
The restaurant is open from 11:00 AM to Midnight Monday through Wednesday and Sunday, and from 11:00 AM to 1:00 AM Thursday through Saturday.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in West Mifflin?
It is located at 9996 Mountain View Drive, West Mifflin, PA 15122, USA.
What categories best describe Buffalo Wild Wings in West Mifflin?
It is a chicken wings restaurant, sports bar, restaurant, and takeout restaurant.
Is Buffalo Wild Wings in West Mifflin currently open or closed?
Buffalo Wild Wings in West Mifflin is currently open and not closed.
Can you provide the contact phone number for Buffalo Wild Wings in West Mifflin?
The main phone number is +1 412-653-3460.
Are there other Buffalo Wild Wings locations near the West Mifflin restaurant?
Yes, there are other Buffalo Wild Wings restaurants nearby that also serve chicken wings and have bar and fast food options.
What shopping options are available near Buffalo Wild Wings in West Mifflin?
Nearby shopping includes Mattress Firm Century III, Marshalls, Kohl's, The Home Depot, SEPHORA, and Vans.
Where can I find pet-related services near Buffalo Wild Wings in West Mifflin?
Near Buffalo Wild Wings, you can find pet services like Vetco Vaccination Clinic, Petco Dog Training, and Petco - Century III for grooming, training, and supplies.
Is there a grocery or liquor store near Buffalo Wild Wings in West Mifflin?
Yes, ALDI USA is a nearby grocery store and supermarket that also offers liquor products.