Many customers praised the attentive and friendly service, particularly highlighting servers like Olivia and Chantile for their exceptional hospitality.
Food Quality
While several reviews praised the food as delicious and authentic, there were notable complaints about inconsistency in flavor and freshness, particularly regarding specific dishes like rice, beans, and fried ice cream.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is generally described as having a lively and welcoming atmosphere, contributing positively to the dining experience.
Inconsistency
Some customers reported issues with service speed and food temperature, indicating a need for improvement in consistency across visits.
WM
Wayne Martin
2 days ago
5.0
Food was amazing!!! Our waitress was also great!!
RH
Randal Hart
Dec 19, 2025
5.0
Best server I had was Olivia good food
SS
Smk
Nov 24, 2025
5.0
Great Mexican food , atmosphere is good !
Food was delicious, hot and filling
We had a very nice meal . I do recommend stopping here if your looking for authentic Mexican food
AA
Ashley Aguirre
Nov 22, 2025
1.0
My daughter and I are from out of town, and she really wanted some rice and beans. We were really looking forward to a good Mexican meal, but unfortunately, this place just didn’t meet our expectations. The Mexican rice tasted like the kind you buy in a box, and it just didn’t have the homemade flavor we were hoping for. My daughter was super hungry so she mixed it with her Beans ate what she could.
The salsa was also a letdown. It didn’t have much flavor or any of that fresh taste and spice we usually look forward to. When the salsa isn’t good, it’s tough to feel excited about the rest of the food.
The fried ice cream was probably the biggest disappointment. The tortilla shell was burnt and tasted bitter, and the ice cream inside was icy and just didn’t taste fresh. We were really hoping for that warm, crispy outside and creamy inside, but it just didn’t come together the way we expected. You know the ice cream is bad when a kid won't eat it.
When it comes to the ice cream, we brought it up to our waitress. Instead of apologizing and offering a solution, perhaps a new one, or removing the item from our bill, they first offered us a $1 off our bill. Instead of management coming to our table, we had to travel to the bar to find her to try to get a better solution. Still no apologies. Told me maybe the cinnamon on the shell was what the burnt taste was. Definitely not. The ice cream we were told was fine because all the rest in the freezer looked fine. In the end, we were offered 3.50 off an ice that was inedible. They claimed that we ate more than half, but it was far from it
I've been in the restaurant business for 20 years, and no manager I have ever worked with would have worked so hard going back and forth with a guest to avoid having to refund $6.00.
Yes $6.00 isn't much, and I definitely could have just paid it and been on my way, but my daughter really wanted that ice cream, and for her not to want to take more than 2 bites really tells you something.
I wouldn’t recommend this place unless they start using fresher ingredients and make authentic food.
Frequently Asked Questions About El Torito Mexican Restaurant
What type of cuisine does El Torito Mexican Restaurant serve?
El Torito Mexican Restaurant serves Mexican cuisine including burritos, tacos, fajitas, and shrimp dishes.
What are the operating hours for El Torito Mexican Restaurant?
The restaurant is open Monday to Thursday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 8:00 PM.
Does El Torito Mexican Restaurant offer dine-in and take-out options?
Yes, El Torito Mexican Restaurant accepts reservations and offers both dine-in and take-out services.
What payment methods are accepted at El Torito Mexican Restaurant?
The restaurant accepts American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Cash, Discover, MasterCard, Samsung Pay, and Visa.
In which languages can I expect service at El Torito Mexican Restaurant?
Service is available in both English and Spanish.
Where is El Torito Mexican Restaurant located?
It is located at 3255 N Susquehanna Trail, Shamokin Dam, PA 17876, USA.
Are there any nearby accommodations for visitors to El Torito Mexican Restaurant?
Yes, the Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Shamokin Dam - Selinsgrove is nearby for visitors needing accommodations.
What nearby dining options exist near El Torito Mexican Restaurant?
Nearby dining options include Casa Sanchez Authentic Mexican Restaurant and Bob Evans, offering a variety of Mexican and American dining experiences.
Are there any nearby services that could assist customers visiting El Torito Mexican Restaurant?
Yes, nearby services include Enterprise Rent-A-Car for travel needs and LibertyX Bitcoin ATM for financial transactions.
Does El Torito Mexican Restaurant have an online presence where I can find more information?
Yes, you can visit their website at https://www.eltoritorestaurant.com/ or check out their Facebook page.