Spread Bagelry

Reviews

• CG

  Courtney Greeley

  Jan 5, 2026
  5.0
  We had a great experience at Spread Bagelry. I ordered The Standard with fluffy eggs, melted Cooper Sharp, and pork roll, and it was everything you want in a breakfast sandwich. We also tried the Za’atar Chicken Salad Sandwich, which was herby, vibrant, and perfectly balanced with golden raisins, crisp lettuce, and tangy pickled red onion. The staff was friendly, the interior was clean and warm, and the overall vibe was welcoming. Would highly recommend.
• GH

  Grace Harrison

  Dec 21, 2025
  2.0
  Food was mid, ambience half made up for it. First of all, not enough cream cheese…if your place is called “spread bagelry” you CANT go light on the “spread,” I want to see my teeth marks. Anyways, it goes beyond the spread: tomato was rock hard, egg kinda tasteless, bagels didn’t taste super fresh, think that whole oven is just for show…then the cappuccino tasted like a cup of steamed milk.
• HM

  Harrison Miller

  Dec 21, 2025
  2.0
  Food was not fresh and overall subpar. Did have a nice atmosphere though.
• MM

  Mike

  Dec 6, 2025
  3.0
  Given this location a few chances. The standard always comes out runny egg or just plain messy - not very put together. It also comes out to like $15 which is really just kind of crazy for a bacon egg and cheese. Tried to go more simple and just order toasted bagel w/spread - received non toasted. Otherwise the coffee is pretty good
• MD

  Madi Duff

  Nov 30, 2025
  3.0
  I was disappointed with my experience today at Spread Bagelry. On multiple occasions when i’ve gone to pickup my online order, I’ve been ignored for several minutes by staff while my order is sitting on the counter. Today, i placed an order online which included the black eyed pea scrapple. An employee told me that they were OOS of the scrapple, and asked if I wanted anything to replace it. Although this wasn’t ideal, I accepted the offer for a side of bacon for my partner instead. After opening the side of bacon, it was a very small portion and did not match the $6 value of the black eyed pea scrapple. I also am not thrilled about the 20% tip being auto-selected for online pickup orders. It feels sneaky and lead to an accidental tip, and i’m sure this has happened to multiple online order customers that are typically in a rush compared to dine-in customers. We enjoyed the quality of the food and hope to see these pain points improved upon in the future.

Frequently Asked Questions About Spread Bagelry