Moio's Italian Pastry Shop, located in Monroeville, PA, specializes in the finest assortment of wedding cakes, pastries, cookies and Italian specialties in the Greater Pittsburgh area.
Many customers praised the freshness and deliciousness of the pastries, cakes, and cannolis, while some reported issues with dryness and staleness in certain items.
Customer Service
The staff received positive feedback for being friendly, accommodating, and helpful, although there were a few instances of poor service reported.
Variety
Customers appreciated the wide selection of baked goods available, including cakes, pastries, and specialty items.
Atmosphere
The bakery is described as charming and inviting, though some noted it can get crowded and loud during busy times.
Value
Many reviews highlighted the reasonable pricing for the quality of the products, with some customers expressing satisfaction with the value for special orders.
MR
M R
Nov 16, 2025
1.0
The mocha bar the cake is dry and has texture of a dish sponge. The icing is also dry and minimal flavor ( it was juet a vanilla cake). The chocolate tort was ok the cake was dry but the Icing was atleast moist. Ive had better eclairs from a box. Customer service was ok due to the attentiveness....Take a look at their ceiling tiles .
MH
Marcella H
Nov 7, 2025
5.0
The owner, Tony is incredibly friendly and accommodating! The prices are amazing and the cakes are to die for🤤we had our wedding cake by them in October. The whole process was awesome! They were always available to communicate with us and answer any questions we had. They just gained new lifelong customers and we plan on ordering from them again. Please use them if you are in need of quality desserts!!!
BG
Brendan Graziano
Oct 30, 2025
5.0
We got cookies and a Cassata for a work event and it was fantastic! Really great array and awesome flavors!
LK
Lauren K
Oct 26, 2025
5.0
​We had the best experience with Moio's Bakery this week, and I had to share the story.
​For our parents' 40th wedding anniversary today, we asked Moio's to recreate their actual wedding cake—the same one they had exactly four decades ago, also made by the bakery. It was a chocolate cake with a raspberry center and classic white buttercream icing.
​The team absolutely nailed it!
​When we brought the cake out, our parents were completely surprised. Seeing that familiar cake after all this time was an awesome moment! It wasn't just a dessert-it was a trip down memory lane. The cake itself was rich, moist, and the buttercream was nice and smooth.
​We are so grateful to everyone at Moio's for the care they put into this special order. They helped us make this milestone celebration unforgettable. If you need a custom cake for a truly special occasion, this is definitely the place to go!
GA
george anton
Oct 15, 2025
2.0
Bought 25 pieces of individual desserts plus a Rum (Baba) cake .
With the exception of a couple of bites the rum cake and 50% of the individual desserts ended up in the waste can.
With the exception of the frosting every one was sooo dry inside that made the dessert very unpleasant to eat.
But they were beautifully displayed and decorated.
The Young ladies that helped me out may I say were very pleasant and polite.
Frequently Asked Questions About Moio's Italian Pastry Shop
Do you do specialty cakes?
Yes, we offer specialty cakes for various occasions.
Do you offer gluten-free or dairy-free options?
We provide a selection of gluten-free and dairy-free cookies and pies for customers with dietary restrictions.
Do you make wedding cakes?
Yes, we create wedding cakes for special occasions.
Do you ship your products?
We offer shipping services for our dry pastries and cookies only.
What types of specialty cakes does Moio's Italian Pastry Shop offer?
Moio's Italian Pastry Shop offers specialty cakes for various occasions, including birthday and wedding cakes.
Do you provide gluten-free or dairy-free dessert options?
Yes, they offer a selection of gluten-free and dairy-free cookies and pies to accommodate dietary restrictions.
Can I order a wedding cake from Moio's Italian Pastry Shop?
Yes, Moio's Italian Pastry Shop creates wedding cakes for special occasions.
Are there shipping options available for your baked goods?
Shipping is available for dry pastries and cookies only.
What are the store hours for Moio's Italian Pastry Shop?
The shop is closed on Mondays. From Tuesday to Saturday, it is open from 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM, and on Sunday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM.
Where is Moio's Italian Pastry Shop located?
It is located at 4209 William Penn Highway, Monroeville, PA 15146, USA.
What payment methods does Moio's Italian Pastry Shop accept?
They accept American Express, Cash, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa.
Is Moio's Italian Pastry Shop near any popular local stores or amenities?
Yes, it is near Gold Rush Monroeville, a jewelry and fashion accessories store, and Penn Station East Coast Subs, a fast food sandwich shop, which customers can visit before or after stopping by the pastry shop.
How can nearby transit options help me visit Moio's Italian Pastry Shop?
The Greyhound Monroeville Bus Stop nearby provides convenient bus service, making it easy for visitors to reach Moio's Italian Pastry Shop without a car.
Are there any nearby coffee shops where I can relax after visiting Moio's Italian Pastry Shop?
Yes, Starbucks is located nearby, offering a great place to enjoy coffee after your visit to Moio's Italian Pastry Shop.