At Papa Johns Pizza in Mechanicsburg, PA, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Mechanicsburg pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Mechanicsburg or stop by 1010 WESLEY DR for carryout to order the best pizza in Mechanicsburg, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Customers reported inconsistent food quality, with some pizzas being undercooked or lacking toppings, while others praised the taste and freshness.
Delivery Issues
Many reviews highlighted problems with delivery times, including late arrivals and missing items, leading to customer frustration.
Customer Service
Feedback on customer service was mixed; some praised friendly staff, while others reported rude interactions and unhelpful responses to complaints.
Hygiene Concerns
Several customers expressed concerns about hygiene practices among staff, particularly regarding food handling and cleanliness.
Value for Money
While some customers appreciated the pricing and deals, others felt the quality did not justify the cost, especially when orders were incorrect or poorly prepared.
CW
Chris Werdz
Jan 31, 2026
2.0
Ordered delivery, tipped $10, didn't knock just quietly put the stuff outside the door in 10 degree weather and left. Second time they knocked but left 3rd party bible thumper paraphernalia in my order....
JO
Jose Soto Ortiz
Jan 30, 2026
5.0
Good price and delicious 😋
EE
Eric
Jan 8, 2026
5.0
Food was delicious, my order was correct, and the guy at the counter was very nice despite me ordering near to closing time.
MA
Megan Aldinger
Nov 14, 2025
2.0
We looked forward to a quick dinner tonight at our local Papa John’s, and while the staff were friendly and welcoming, I was disappointed to observe a number of hygiene issues that I believe need attention. At pickup the register staff were handling money, wiping sweat off their brows, and were pizza-twirling none of whom appeared to be wearing gloves. I also noticed that gentleman with long hair were wearing only hats, no hair nets, and there didn’t seem to be any protection for loose hair in the food-prep area..
I understand that everyone is busy and working hard, and again the staff were kind and efficient—but given that proper hygiene is such a core part of food safety, it would make me feel much more confident if all staff handling food or customer-facing tasks were wearing gloves when appropriate, and if loose hair was fully restrained or covered by nets. I love your pizza and hope to continue coming back—just hoping to see these small improvements for peace of mind.
HR
Hanne R
Oct 13, 2025
1.0
The pizza was dry, hardly any sauce and hardly any cheese, they couldn’t have made it in a skimpier way. Asked for chicken and bacon and could barely find any on the pizza. Don’t waste your money.