Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• HE

  heather Elizabeth

  Apr 19, 2026
  5.0
  Ordered 2 New York Style pizza both were hot and delicious being late at 10:00pm we were so happy with how DELICIOUS these were hot and made perfectly. Also, ordered 2 new chicken bacon ranch subs and they were DELICIOUS! This was our 3rd time ordering recently and each time they have been just as delicious!! Very friendly as well. Definetly BEST pizza in the Meadville area and APPRECIATE the late hours they are open!!! Definetly will be back!
• CM

  CHIP MARTIN

  Apr 10, 2026
  1.0
  I have read others that say the one star reviews are wrong for this location. Well I'm here to say that if I could give ZERO Stars I would. First time at this new pizza option in town and WOW what a disappointment. We always order the same pizza and toppings in order to compare fairly with others around town. This PJ's pizza is by far the worst we have ever had. Ordered peperoni and onions , simple right ? Not so my friends !! Peperoni usually means Peperoni , not the lack of peperoni. We had a 8 cut pizza and literally 3 of the 8 slices had no peperoni AT ALL ?? The remaining 5 slices had a total peperoni count that we would normally see on just 2 slices. In other words Where's The Beef , or in this case the Peperoni ? Their moto is Better Ingredients - Better Pizza - How about No Ingredients No More Business From Us !!
• EE

  Evil E

  Mar 3, 2026
  1.0
  Terrible taste like cardboard. Slow service
• RH

  Robert Hass

  Feb 26, 2026
  1.0
  The staff was nice, but the pizza is by far the worst pizza in town. The crust is dry and tasteless, with very little sauce, and the toppings and cheese are very thin. This is flavorless, "corporate" pizza. You're way better off getting excellent local pizza at Smokey Martins or Bella Bella Mozzarella.
• CB

  Chris Brazil

  Jan 30, 2026
  1.0
  So tonight in Meadville pa I waited over an hour for my pizza kept being told 10 more mins. Well after an hour later I get the pizza bring it home I live 2mins down the road. My pizza was so dry and almost burnt it was very disappointing. After tonight I don't think I'll ever be back there!