Customers praised the hoagies for their fresh ingredients and delicious flavors, although some reported issues with specific items like cheesesteaks being dry or bland.
Order Accuracy
A significant number of reviews highlighted problems with order accuracy, including missing ingredients and incorrect sandwiches.
Service Speed
Many customers expressed frustration with slow service and long wait times, particularly for online orders.
Staff Friendliness
The staff received positive feedback for being friendly and helpful, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere.
Pricing Concerns
Several reviews mentioned that the prices were considered high relative to the quality and portion sizes of the sandwiches.
PS
Pete Shaffalo
Oct 25, 2025
5.0
FANTASTIC cheese steak
GM
Grubz Magoo
Sep 17, 2025
2.0
I have ordered here quite often and they never seem to get an order right. I'd understand if there were substitutions or extras involved but missing an ingredient on a standard 3 ingredient sandwich is laughable. I have had times where they called me to tell they didn't have something in stock and they would refund. Never got the refund. Food is great when it's right. At least location that happens about 20% of the time. Never again
BB
BBWL
Aug 14, 2025
1.0
Food was awful. Ordered lunch for clients and spent $240 . Needless to say I was embarrassed after most people took a few bites then threw their sandwiches away... cheesesteak was one of the worst I've had, dried out and cheese not even melted, the others who had the same agreed... luckily I ordered chips for everyone so at least something was good.... do NOT recommend
RR
Rso123
Jul 30, 2025
1.0
Hoagies are over priced but pretty good unfortunately the service is absolutely terrible and you really can’t count on them if you’re in a hurry. They have screwed up 2 out of my last 3 orders. Not recommend! Try Jersey Mikes up the street.
SS
Steven Sion
Jul 18, 2025
5.0
Good Hoagie, definitely can tell the good quality of meats compared to other Hoagie restaurants.
What are the operating hours of PrimoHoagies in McMurray, PA?
PrimoHoagies is open daily from 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM.
Where is PrimoHoagies located in McMurray?
PrimoHoagies is located at 4080 Washington Road, McMurray, PA 15317, USA.
Does PrimoHoagies offer delivery and pickup services?
Yes, PrimoHoagies offers in-store pickup, delivery, and same-day delivery services.
How can I place an online order for PrimoHoagies?
You can place an order online at https://order.primohoagies.com/ or through their mobile apps on Android and iOS.
What types of payment does PrimoHoagies accept?
PrimoHoagies accepts American Express, Apple Pay, Cash, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa payments.
Does PrimoHoagies have menu options for vegetarians and vegans?
Yes, PrimoHoagies serves vegetarian and vegan options.
Is PrimoHoagies family-friendly and does it welcome children?
Yes, PrimoHoagies welcomes children and has seating available for dine-in.
Are there nearby places where I can grab coffee before or after visiting PrimoHoagies?
Yes, Starbucks, a nearby coffee shop, is close to PrimoHoagies where you can enjoy coffee before or after your meal.
Which nearby restaurants can I visit along with PrimoHoagies if I want a variety of dining options?
Nearby dining options include Aladdin's (Lebanese and Mediterranean cuisine), Penny's Diner (American diner), El Campesino (Mexican restaurant and bar), and Max & Erma's (American restaurant).
Are there any nearby services I can access while visiting PrimoHoagies?
Yes, nearby services include Model Cleaners (dry cleaning and laundromat), Verizon Wireless stores, Supercuts hair salon, and PNC Bank.