Customers frequently praised the food for being delicious, fresh, and well-prepared, with standout items like the mushroom soup and various breakfast dishes.
Service
The service received mixed reviews; while many customers appreciated the friendly and attentive staff, some reported issues with slow service and order accuracy.
Cleanliness
Most reviews highlighted the cleanliness of the restaurant, with many noting a tidy environment and well-maintained dining area.
Value
Several customers expressed concerns about pricing, feeling that some menu items were overpriced relative to their quality.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's cozy and inviting atmosphere was frequently mentioned, contributing to a pleasant dining experience.
JL
Jaan H. Lutter
Nov 14, 2025
4.0
Café Americana is a lovely place. Definitely worth the trip best place for breakfast in town. Never disappointed
LB
Lawrence Barry
Oct 22, 2025
5.0
Tried mushroom soup not expecting the best mushroom soup I have ever had. The tacos were incredible as well. Chicken on corn taco.
TB
T B
Oct 8, 2025
5.0
Always a good menu. Great avacado cobb salad with warm tender grilled chicken. Balsamic dressing paired well with the salad. Mom had delicious waffle with strawberries and whip cream. Thank you!
KK
Kelly
Aug 27, 2025
4.0
This was our first time dining here. It had good overall reviews, so we went. My son ordered French toast, and it looked delicious. He said it was really good. I had the ranchero omelet. It's supposed to have chicken, beans, corn, and cheese inside of it. It sounded great. It was the smallest, neatest omelet I've ever seen. It was cold and barely had anything inside of it. I didn't see any chicken or corn. Like their main focus was presentation. I really liked the potatoes that came with the dish. The people were nice, and service was OK. I thought the atmosphere was really cute. We just ate and left. The lunch pictures posted on other reviews look really good, especially that French onion soup. I wouldn't mind going back to try other items.
AN
Anne Nuse
Aug 26, 2025
5.0
Great, attentive service. Our server answered all of my questions about my food choices & gave good feedback and advice. Had the tropical shrimp tacos which were fresh & delicious. The peach iced tea tasted freshly brewed. The Matcha/Mango drink was tasty and a good accompaniment to the tacos.
I’ve been a customer of Cafe Americana for as long as it has been in New Garden and this was by far the best experience I’ve had. Although. I’ve never truly been disappointed.