Original Italian Pizza Rt 22

Reviews

• JC

  Jacob Callis

  6 days ago
  1.0
  you advertise you close at 9:30 and i get there at 8:35 and you’re closed walking out. really great communication to your customers
• CS

  Charles Shepker

  Mar 30, 2026
  2.0
  We stopped here after visiting the local college after reading some reviews. People please stop lying on reviews. The best thing about this place was our server, she was great. The fried cauliflower was actually good as well. We ordered a Sicilian pizza. Which could have been good if most of the toppings had been fresh. The dough was not done in the middle of the pie. Maybe it was just our luck but will skip this place on the next visit.
• TS

  Todd Shatzer

  Mar 24, 2026
  5.0
  Stop there when we going walleye fishing or when we want a good pizza at home. I drive from Williamsburg to enjoy this place. Pizza is all I ever had and the sauce is delicious. I’ll be trying a hoagie next time.
• DC

  Dennis Corl

  Mar 13, 2026
  5.0
  Great Sub
• CC

  Candice Taylor (Candi)

  Mar 9, 2026
  3.0
  The food was really good however the service sucked. I had to ask for refil and still didn't get them I had to remind her that my meal came with bread that I also didn't get until I was leaving. She said it was because it was still in the oven yet I watched 2 other tables get their. Bread after I asked for mine. There was only about 5 tables in the whole restrant with 2 servers working the floor and I had to remind them to do their job. It might sound like I'm just being petty but I was a server for many many years and I expect to be served with the same standard of service I would provide my guests.

Frequently Asked Questions About Original Italian Pizza Rt 22