Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• PB

  Penny Bell

  Apr 8, 2026
  5.0
  Went in to pick up a door dash order they made it when we got there and than made us a pizza for the wait super nice people. It was a great surprise ty
• TS

  Thomas Sigurdsson

  Mar 14, 2026
  5.0
  It's Papa John's. It tastes the same every where. Is there better local? Yes. But sometimes you want consistency. Sometimes you want 2 pizzas and wings for 20 bucks. Don't listen to haters. It's mechanized mass produced perfection. That's why it's a national chain and your local favorite isn't.
• WH

  WillIam Harlos

  Feb 17, 2026
  3.0
  Its a papa John's in the worst imaginable gas station. People on doordash who havent been inside this Shell DO NOT know who theyre ordering from. WARNING, DO NOT ORDER IN THE MORNING OR BEFORE NOON! The woman making your food does not wear gloves and has been seen on multiple occasions making pizza and handling products and cash at the register without washing her hands. If you do plan on ordering pizza, make sure to always get it well done! Theyre ovens are not hot enough for the baking process, leaving the pizza flimsy, and doughy. Do not walk in order either, use the app, its cheaper and they can update the app manually from the store telling you when its done. That is, if they actually used it. Always give them an extra 10 min. They are always understaffed and take forever with people food.
• JR

  Jennifer Ryan

  Feb 14, 2026
  1.0
  Had the pepperoni pizza, tasted gross and severely undercooked.
• JK

  John Kandrovy

  Jan 31, 2026
  2.0
  Between the Dominos store on Rt 6 and Papa John's at the end of Main street, you can find better quality pizza in Honesdale. The fact of the matter is that pizza in general from all major pizza chains went down hill years ago. They have the same suppliers and followed the same corporate cost cutting. The dough and subsequent crust are the same, the cheese which melts the same and texture being its fake cheese that produces the same burn marks is identical. They all have become gas station quality pizza ( ironically this store is part of a gas station) and the Rt6 Highhouse gas station/Convenience store and deli makes a better pizza. It just sucks because some of us have memories of when Papa John's was above the rest.