Stuff'D Steaks & Hoagies

Reviews

• AW

  April Weidner

  Jan 2, 2026
  5.0
  As a vegetarian, a cheesesteak joint isn’t usually my go-to. After seeing all of the positive (and negative 😢) news about their commitment to feeding any and everyone, I wanted to show my support. On my first trip I tried to veggie hoagie. It was so good! Fresh veggies, cheese, and hearty roll. My husband also loved his Italian hoagie, just as it comes. After a brief online convo where I asked if a hot veggie option could be made, I ventured back for a second time. This time I asked for a custom “cheesesteak” with just toppings and cheese. The woman taking my order was so kind and agreed that even without the meat it sounded pretty good. Well, let me tell you - that was one of the best subs I’ve had. I know it may sound strange to meat-eaters, but wow was it good! Hopefully it wasn’t too much of a pain to make because I will definitely be back to order that again! Thanks Stuff’d for being so kind and making such delicious food!
• MB

  Michelle Beech

  Jan 1, 2026
  5.0
  ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I don’t say this lightly: this was the best Philly cheesesteak I’ve had in my entire life. My daughter and I stopped into Stuff’D while in Hershey, and from the first bite to the last, it was unreal. Perfectly seasoned steak, melty cheese, fresh bread — the kind of sandwich you keep thinking about long after you leave. But what really made it special? The people. Every single employee was incredibly kind, welcoming, and genuinely happy we were there. I’m pretty sure we met the owner too, and the hospitality was just as top-tier as the food. This wasn’t just a meal — it was a great experience with my kid that I’ll remember. If you’re anywhere near Hershey, do not skip this place. I’d recommend it 100 times over. We’ll absolutely be back.⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I don’t say this lightly: this was the best Philly cheesesteak I’ve had in my entire life. My daughter and I stopped into Stuff’D while in Hershey, and from the first bite to the last, it was unreal. Perfectly seasoned steak, melty cheese, fresh bread — the kind of sandwich you keep thinking about long after you leave. But what really made it special? The people. Every single employee was incredibly kind, welcoming, and genuinely happy we were there. I’m pretty sure we met the owner too, and the hospitality was just as top-tier as the food. This wasn’t just a meal — it was a great experience with my kid that I’ll remember. If you’re anywhere near Hershey, do not skip this place. I’d recommend it 100 times over. We’ll absolutely be back.
• LB

  L.D Blue

  Dec 30, 2025
  5.0
  Recently back in November I posted a review for this establishment when "Stuff'd Steaks" in Hershey was helping recipients of SNAP enjoy free cuisine through their tough times. At the time I was going through chaos where a client I did contracting work for ripped me off for an entire job when she sold her house, and moved away without paying. I got SNAP but , just in time for the shutdown. I deleted that review out of the fact I wish to remain anonymous, and not share my real full name with the public due to my very toxic family who may see me online. At the time Stuff'd Steaks' quality of their food, the fries that took me back to my childhood, and genuine compassion struck me so hard it compelled me to write an immediate 5 star review. I can tell anyone reading this that the same treatment I received that first day, holds true months later, despite me not having too many chances to go back. Times are still super tough for me. I am still facing eviction, and just taking one day at a time, while I find more contracting jobs. But of the the times I've visited this cozy little restaurant, each and every occasion was a memorable one. Each visit was better than the last. They even played Sinatra for me the day I came back after finding the review I gave them got popular on Facebook. I can say though since that review Brian and his family have simply shown me nothing but compassion, and kindness throughout some of the toughest months of my entire adult life. They provided me free PRIME hydration water. Bags of my favorite Colombian breath mints. And endless positivity. They even slipped a $20 dollar bill into my bag one night, along with 2 free large Italian hoagies, with real good quality Italian cold cuts, and top quality cheeses, after telling them I barely had gas left in my car to get to a job. My mouth is watering just thinking about their cheese steaks, hoagies, fries, tiny little Colombian Mints, and sweet chewy fruit candies included at their condiment station. My God's Trousers! They even included a homemade Hershey's Chocolate Chip Cookie from Hershey homemade line of cookies, probably made right across the street. Tasted fresh made. They are some of the best cookies. Only bad thing is my doctor did mention my cholesterol took a huge spike in November to 320 thanks to my strong love of their classic Cheese steak with provolone :-). Their Cheese steak is TOO good. I get goosebumps, and my mouth waters just thinking about it. It's an experience every time. I never go home hungry, or sad from this place. The regular customers are an absolute joy to talk to as well. I met one guy named Dave who talked to me for an hour about life, and current state of the country. But to please my doctor, and in the spirit of trying new things, my plan is try their Turkey Hoagie with their homemade ranch sauce the next time I visit. (much healthier option). I'm sure they could whip up a salad together for me too with lettuce tomato , onion, oil , and vinegar. And some of their delicious locally sourced sweet Italian peppers. I may have not been in there recently, but I know when I do go back I will be treated like family. And that's something a single, struggling working man like myself really needs when their own family sucks! Brian, thanks man. You are a good person who breaks all boundaries of diversity with your clientele. You can spot intelligence when you see it. You know what quality is. You know what hard work is. You're teaching valuable lessons to your family, and providing great food + a positive experience to the entire community, where "EVERYONE EATS". You don't judge someone for how much money they make, you judge them based on the integrity of their character! That level of dedication shines through with the entire atmosphere of your restaurant. The real lesson here is that for every 100 negative people, or money-hungry, greedy corporations in the world. There is always 1 family like Brian, his wife, kids, and employees who more than compensate for it. See you guys soon! -L.D
• RE

  RICK EVANS

  Dec 29, 2025
  1.0
  I was going to eat here after seeing this restaurant on the local news asking for support of small businesses . I have share this news article & reviews, particularly the one with Brian arguing with a customer on a public platform. We are here at Hershey Theater renovating it, and yes "we care " Brian about small business & customer service. Anyone in business period, should not insult or argue with a customer on a public platform. This behavior has cost your struggling restaurant more loses. In the future think first, someone is always watching.
• AH

  Alicia Hall

  Dec 23, 2025
  5.0
  This place is worth the hype! It came highly recommended from several different locals when we had a hankering for a good cheesesteak and they didn’t steer us wrong. The portions are large and loaded with all the good stuff, especially their signature cheesesteak. They were also happy to accommodate a gluten allergy by serving cheesesteak over fries, loaded with our choice of toppings. Our favorites were the “Sweet Heat” sub and “loaded fries.” Yum! The service was fast and friendly. We will definitely return on our next trip to Hershey!

Frequently Asked Questions About Stuff'D Steaks & Hoagies