Many customers praised the delicious pizza and other menu items, highlighting the homemade quality and generous portions.
Service Issues
Several reviews noted problems with order accuracy, delivery delays, and unprofessional behavior from staff, leading to customer dissatisfaction.
Friendly Atmosphere
Customers frequently mentioned the friendly and welcoming staff, creating a pleasant dining experience.
Inconsistent Experience
While many enjoyed their meals, there were reports of inconsistent food quality and service, with some customers expressing disappointment in their orders.
YU
yujun Un
5 days ago
5.0
Had the Sicily pizza with pepperoni and sausage. The crust was amazing 👏. Husband and I also order the BBQ wings which was cooked to perfection. Definitely would go back when I'm in the area!
SM
Scott Moore
5 days ago
5.0
Excellent Pizza shop. So glad it has returned to operation.
AD
Anna Dean
Dec 28, 2025
5.0
Always delicious pizza, love that they have persona size pizzas. Delivery is always before the estimated time. Ordering online is super easy
AL
Andrew Lehman
Dec 13, 2025
5.0
Good pizza. Just wish they had banana peppers and hots as options. Friendly staff. Hopefully they can withstand the higher prices as eating out isn’t cheap anymore.
Frequently Asked Questions About The Heart of Sicily
What are the regular operating hours for The Heart of Sicily?
The Heart of Sicily is open Monday through Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, and on Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM.
Does The Heart of Sicily offer delivery and pickup services?
Yes, The Heart of Sicily offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
What are the delivery hours at The Heart of Sicily?
Delivery is available Monday through Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 8:45 PM, and on Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 9:45 PM.
When is The Heart of Sicily closed during the holidays?
The Heart of Sicily is closed on December 25th each year and has limited hours on December 24th, open from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM.
What services are available for takeout at The Heart of Sicily?
Takeout services are available daily from 11:00 AM to 8:45 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and until 9:45 PM on Friday and Saturday.
Where is The Heart of Sicily located?
The Heart of Sicily is located at 3186 N George St, Emigsville, PA 17318, USA.
Can you recommend nearby places of interest around The Heart of Sicily?
Nearby places include Emigsville Park for outdoor activities, Otterbein United Methodist Church for religious services, and York MarKet for grocery shopping and gas.
Are there any nearby fitness or sports facilities close to The Heart of Sicily?
Yes, nearby fitness and sports options include East Coast Volleyball and Mayfield Mat Academy, both offering gym and sports league activities.
What options are available for customers needing automotive or moving services near The Heart of Sicily?
Customers can access U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer nearby for truck rentals and automotive needs, as well as Stitch and Stereo for auto customization and repair.
How can customers view the menu and place orders for The Heart of Sicily?
Customers can view the menu and place orders online at https://theheartofsicilypa.com/menu.