Out of the Fire Cafe

Reviews

• EJ

  Ed Hill Jr

  2 days ago
  3.0
  $60 filet. Nice cut of meat ruined with rub. Tasted nothing but salt. Drinks are expensive and small. Service was top tier.
• JD

  John Daly

  2 days ago
  5.0
  Our meal and service was exceptional! This was a surprise find. You’ll need your GPS as the restaurant doesn’t front the Main Street. The two “appetizer” plates we ordered were huge and we didn’t need to order an entree afterwards. The hummus appetizer was particularly generous.
• SH

  Shannon Hirsch

  2 days ago
  4.0
  We didn't have reservations but hey were able to seat us in a both right away. The menu was small but well developed. The salmon salad was delicious. The swordfish special was disappointing but was good. The swordfish was slightly overcooked. The children's menu looked great. It's always nice to see options out of the usual (chicken nuggets, grilled cheese, buttered noodles, burger) and the portions were huge for a child. Everyone was nice but it seemed like they were busy and we didn't have reservations so it was slow to get our meal and the check-ins were not frequent. Overall we were pleased with our meal and experience.
• SS

  samoh

  3 days ago
  4.0
  First time was a great experience and food. We went back but steak was greedy and service was poor
• AB

  Ashley Bianchi

  Apr 7, 2026
  5.0
  We stopped spur of the moment and we are so glad we did! I have gotten steaks at steak houses that couldn’t get my steak right, But this place was the absolute BEST! Food is flavorful and cooked perfect! Will definitely drive 3.5 hours to go back! Our waiter was beyond great! We had no complaints at all, which is very impressive bc I always find something to complain about! Make sure you’re paying your cook good!! A good cook is hard to find and you got a phenomenal one! Thank you all for the great experience we have been telling everyone about you!

Frequently Asked Questions About Out of the Fire Cafe