Customers generally praised the deliciousness and freshness of the food, particularly the pizza and strombolis, though there were complaints about undercooked items and inconsistency in quality.
Service
While many reviews highlighted friendly and efficient staff, there were notable complaints about slow service and issues with order accuracy.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as clean and welcoming, contributing positively to the overall dining experience.
Pricing
Customers found the prices reasonable, although some felt they were becoming too high for the quality received.
KH
Khyler Holderbaum
Jan 6, 2026
5.0
You need to listen to me when I tell you this. But Claysburg Pizza has the best Ham Stromboli in the US. As someone who’s driven the whole way to CT to try Sally’s. This is the Sally’s a pizza equivalent of Stromboli! Amazing!
BB
Brad
Jan 5, 2026
4.0
Had there Pizza and stromboli. All very good.
JJ
JillEin
Dec 29, 2025
5.0
Food is always delicious and delivered HOTT.
TL
thomas lego
Dec 25, 2025
1.0
Order taco stromboli, ans the top side is golden brown and crispy and thick but the inside is not cooked at all. You can even see shreds of cheddar uncooked. The bottom side is not even a centimeter thick and soggy and uncooked. Its gross. Their other strombolis are the same. I wouldnt even call this stromboli, it shames the good name of a classic pizza shop item. I got 2 and they were both like itm. Similarly my father got the same and pepperoni ones and its the same thing raw dough..and the ham is so thick and of bad quality the water (because same is mostly watet) dripped out of the thing. You got a dough issue, quality of ingredients issue, bake process issue, you have beautiful deck ovens but bake on a pan??? Weird. Then the price for it.
AW
Ashley Walters
Dec 14, 2025
5.0
Hot strombolis and pizza on a cold winter night! Delicious!