Many customers praised the home-cooked meals and specific dishes like the breakfast sausage and chipped beef, while some found the food bland or overcooked.
Service
The staff received numerous compliments for being friendly, attentive, and creating a welcoming atmosphere.
Value
Customers appreciated the reasonable prices and good portion sizes, often noting the affordability of the meals.
Atmosphere
The diner is described as cozy and nostalgic, with a homey feel that appeals to locals and visitors alike.
EI
Edgar Iwamoto
Jan 3, 2026
5.0
Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful place to dine! Fare is well worth the wait, friendly, attentive service and delicious meals!
DL
Dave Luckenbaugh
Oct 21, 2025
5.0
Nice place, good food, the people are freindly.
AP
Al Parrillo
Oct 9, 2025
5.0
This place is quaint and perfect for sitting with a friend. The food is excellent and the options are perfect, great home cooked food and amazing homemade Greek breakfast sausage patties. Get a stack!
KH
Kevin Heckendorn
Sep 28, 2025
5.0
Do yourself a favor and take a little trip back in time, drop by this Carlisle icon. Same people, great food (the sausage for breakfast is fantastic) and great prices. We no longer live in the area but whenever we visit we will always try to stop by and savor the memories.
Frequently Asked Questions About John's Hideaway Restaurant
Where is John's Hideaway Restaurant located?
John's Hideaway Restaurant is located at 302 N College St, Carlisle, PA 17013, USA.
What are the operating hours of John's Hideaway Restaurant?
The restaurant is open Monday through Saturday from 6:00 AM to 7:30 PM and is closed on Sundays.
Since when has John's Hideaway Restaurant been in business?
John's Hideaway Restaurant has been in business since 1963.
What payment options does John's Hideaway Restaurant accept?
The restaurant accepts cash and checks as payment options.
What type of cuisine and dining style does John's Hideaway Restaurant offer?
It is a family-style breakfast restaurant serving American cuisine.
Which languages are spoken at John's Hideaway Restaurant?
English is the primary language spoken at the restaurant.
What attractions or facilities are nearby John's Hideaway Restaurant?
Nearby places include the Carlisle Fencing Club, Carlisle Parks & Recreation Department, and the Stuart Community Center, which offer various sports and recreation opportunities.
Are there educational institutions close to John's Hideaway Restaurant?
Yes, Dickinson College's Chemistry Department, Department of Physics & Astronomy, The Clarke Forum, and The Quarry cafe are nearby.
If I'm visiting the Carlisle Borough Police Department, is John's Hideaway Restaurant nearby for a meal?
Yes, John's Hideaway Restaurant is located near the Carlisle Borough Police Department, making it a convenient dining option before or after your visit.
How can I contact John's Hideaway Restaurant for inquiries or reservations?
You can reach John's Hideaway Restaurant by phone at +1 717-243-6760.