Customers have mixed experiences with food quality, with some praising the pizza and cheesesteaks while others report issues like soggy wraps and greasy pizzas.
Service Issues
Many reviews highlight inconsistent service, including long wait times for orders and poor customer service experiences.
Customer Experience
While some customers appreciate the friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere, others report negative interactions and a decline in service quality since the change in ownership.
Value for Money
Several customers feel that the prices are reasonable for the quality of food, although some express dissatisfaction with the value received for their orders.
Menu Variety
The menu is noted for its extensive variety, with many customers enjoying the diverse offerings including vegetarian options and specialty pizzas.
SG
Shane Guzowski
Nov 8, 2025
5.0
Im going to be honest, I have never had their food YET! But I lost my wallet and it showed up in their parking lot and the Owner Ender got a hold of me via Messenger and told me to pick it up anytime....Very nice staff and I consider myself lucky that these are trustworthy people! THANK YOU ENDER AND TEAM! Once I get my debit card back, I will be sure to go back and pick up some food!
KK
Ken Knasiak
Nov 1, 2025
1.0
Called in an order yesterday at 4:15 for 2 pizzas to be ready at 5:00.... arrived at 5:10 and was told only 1 pizza was ready. Waited until 6:10 for the 2nd pizza... all the while the 1st pizza sat on top of the oven for over an hour.
Come on you can do better than that and we all knew it was busy....but?
JJ
John C. Saccomandi Jr
Oct 9, 2025
5.0
Best pizza joint in Delco. Consistent quality, great pricing. 2 toppings 16 inch large for $20.49.
FD
FrankieJ dwm_edc
Sep 30, 2025
5.0
Great pizza, and most of their other dishs are pretty great as well. But cant beat their pizza. I debate back and forth on whether this one or the Collingdale store are better. Really both are great cant go wrong either way.
BL
Brian Lafferty
Sep 18, 2025
1.0
I’ve ordered from this place a few times now, and unfortunately, it’s been a consistently mediocre experience each time. This last order was no different.
Every time I’ve called for delivery, I end up on hold for 10 minutes before they can even take my order. Super frustrating, but anyway This time, after waiting on hold I ordered 12 boneless wings and a chicken wrap, and a with a delivery tip, the total came out to $39 definitely not cheap for what I received.
When the food arrived, the wrap was soggy, which made the fries feel like they were drenched in water. Not a great texture, to say the least. As for the boneless wings? Complete letdown. They had no crunch whatsoever—more like mushy meatballs than crispy wings. Definitely not what I was expecting.
Given my experience, I wouldn’t recommend this place. It’s just been consistently disappointing, and I can’t see myself ordering from here again.
Frequently Asked Questions About Femi's Pizza Party of Brookhaven
Do you have any dietary restriction options?
Yes, we do have gluten-free pizza and vegan options.
What are the operating hours of Femi's Pizza Party of Brookhaven?
We are open Monday to Thursday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to midnight, and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 10:00 PM.
Does Femi's Pizza Party offer gluten-free or vegan options?
Yes, we offer gluten-free pizza and vegan options to accommodate dietary restrictions.
What types of food can I order at Femi's Pizza Party of Brookhaven?
You can enjoy pizza, burgers, salads, wings, hoagies, cheesesteaks, appetizers, stromboli, steaks, quesadillas, chicken, Italian entrees, and seafood.
Which payment methods are accepted at Femi's Pizza Party of Brookhaven?
We accept American Express, Apple Pay, Cash, Check, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa.
How can I contact Femi's Pizza Party of Brookhaven?
You can reach us at +1 610-872-1010 or email femispizza@hotmail.com.
Where is Femi's Pizza Party of Brookhaven located?
We are located at 4225 Edgmont Ave, Brookhaven, PA 19015, USA.
Do you offer dine-in, carry out, and delivery services?
Yes, we provide dine-in, carry out, and delivery services.
What nearby pizza options are available if I want to explore other local restaurants?
Besides Femi's Pizza Party, nearby pizza places include Domino's Pizza and Pat's Pizza & Pasta. You can consider these if you're looking to try other styles or locations.
Are there nearby recreational or fitness centers near Femi's Pizza Party of Brookhaven?
Yes, Studio X Mixed Martial Arts & Fitness is nearby, which is great if you want to work out before or after enjoying a meal here.
What local shops and services can I visit near Femi's Pizza Party of Brookhaven?
Nearby you can find Shear Bliss Hair Salon for beauty needs, Total Team Solutions for fashion, and Dippin' Dots if you're in the mood for ice cream.