Bruegger’s bakes up authentic New York style bagels every morning, ready to be topped with our signature made-in-Vermont cream cheese or perfect for a variety of breakfast and deli sandwiches alongside tasty sides of hashbrowns, muffins, sweets, and custom blends of hot and iced coffee. Breakfast & lunch catering is available by ordering online. In a hurry? Order Ahead using the Bruegger’s mobile app.
Customers generally enjoy the bagels and breakfast sandwiches, but there are frequent complaints about incorrect orders and inconsistent preparation.
Service Issues
Many reviews highlight poor customer service, including long wait times, disorganization, and unfriendly staff.
Cleanliness and Management
Several customers noted cleanliness issues and poor management practices, leading to dissatisfaction with the overall experience.
Ordering Process
The recent change in the ordering process has caused confusion and frustration among customers, leading to longer wait times and order errors.
Value for Money
While some customers find the bagels delicious, others feel the prices are too high for the quality and service received.
NL
Nica Lovinu
Jan 1, 2026
1.0
Foods good, but not going back to this location, messed up my order.
BM
Betty Mcpherson
Dec 11, 2025
5.0
Always great staff. Great bagels and coffee
TC
T C
Nov 26, 2025
5.0
I love Bruegger’s Bagels! The one I used to go to (Cochran) closed a while ago and I held out hopes that it would come back for far too long, but now it’s some healthy fast food place. Boo.
Anyway, this location is great: always clean and well-stocked. Bruegger’s Bagels are far superior to Einstein’s, Panera, etc., so I’m always happy to drive the extra 20-25 minutes to get some.
Please never close!
DH
Darren Hatcher
Nov 11, 2025
3.0
They always follow directions pretty well on a custom bagel sandwich and it's always edible. Sometimes they don't toast the bagels enough but sometimes they do so it's hard to know when to say double toasted or not say it since I just want it toasted so it's lightly brown ya know? They're really slow, drive-thru especially like they are constantly understaffed or just slow workers. I still prefer this place over the local Dunkin donuts any day.
DR
Dianne Wilk, Realtor
Nov 10, 2025
5.0
I absolutely love their bagels! Authentic style NY bagels are boiled (not baked) creating an irresistible slightly firm outer shell with a soft chewy interior. I drive nearly 30 minutes to go get Brueggers bagels, ignoring the other bagel company store that is less than a mile from my home. It’s absolutely worth the trip though I do wish they would reopen a Peters Twp store.
Frequently Asked Questions About Bruegger's Bagels
What types of bagels and sandwiches does Bruegger's Bagels offer?
Bruegger's Bagels offers authentic New York style bagels, including gourmet topped bagels and popular sandwiches like the Farmhouse Egg Sandwich, Vermonter Egg Sandwich, Western Egg Sandwich, and Sriracha Honey Sunrise Egg Sandwich.
What are the opening hours for Bruegger's Bagels at 5213 Library Road, Bethel Park?
Bruegger's Bagels is open every day from 6:00 AM to 2:00 PM.
Does Bruegger's Bagels provide catering services?
Yes, they offer breakfast and lunch catering that can be ordered online.
What pickup and delivery options are available at Bruegger's Bagels?
They provide in-store pickup, delivery, same day delivery, and no-contact delivery services.
What payment methods can customers use at Bruegger's Bagels?
Customers can pay with American Express, Visa, Mastercard, Discover, cash, and various mobile payment options like Apple Pay, Android Pay, Samsung Pay, and contactless payments.
Is there parking available when visiting Bruegger's Bagels?
Yes, there is free street parking and free parking lots available near the location.
Can I order ahead using a mobile app for Bruegger's Bagels?
Yes, you can order ahead using the Bruegger's mobile app available for both Android and iOS devices.
What nearby restaurants are close to Bruegger's Bagels for other dining options?
Nearby dining options include Moe's Southwest Grill for Mexican and American cuisines, Starbucks for coffee and snacks, Arby's for fast food sandwiches, Taco Bell for fast food, and Barley's and Hop's beer garden.
Are there any nearby shops or services where I can run errands before or after visiting Bruegger's Bagels?
Yes, nearby you will find The UPS Store 1360 for printing and packing needs, T-Mobile for mobile phone services, Rite Aid convenience store, RadioShack for electronics, and South Park Shops for various shopping needs.
What health or wellness facilities are located near Bruegger's Bagels?
Nearby health and wellness facilities include Quest Diagnostics for laboratory testing, Massage Envy for massage and skin care services, VIP Petcare Wellness Center for veterinary services, and Alcoholism and Drug Detox Help for alternative medicine.