While many customers praised the seafood boils and specific dishes like fried green tomatoes and jambalaya, several reviews highlighted issues with bland flavors, overcooked seafood, and inconsistent quality.
Service Issues
Numerous reviews mentioned slow service, long wait times for food and drinks, and a lack of attentiveness from staff, leading to a disappointing dining experience for many.
Cleanliness Concerns
Several customers reported unsanitary conditions in the restaurant, including dirty tables and bathrooms, which negatively impacted their overall experience.
Value for Money
Many customers felt that the prices were high relative to the portion sizes and quality of food received, with some expressing regret over their spending.
Positive Experiences
Despite the criticisms, there were numerous positive comments about the friendly staff, enjoyable atmosphere, and specific dishes that customers loved, indicating that some patrons had a great experience.
BK
Brayden Key
Jan 18, 2026
5.0
The chicken strips are so good and well seasoned and frys have a lot of sontness. Drinks are good (9/10) and lobster...MM so good. 10 stars
ZW
Zoe Whitfield
Jan 16, 2026
3.0
Over hyped, over priced and overall disappointed.
Waited forever for our order to be taken, while people who arrived after us and were still waiting for their party had their orders taken first. Didn’t seem very busy at all either.
Over 30 minutes in and still hadn’t gotten our drinks, then got a soda with absolutely no syrup in it.
We’re told they were out of garlic butter , and then told they were trying to “conserve” it.
Fried green tomatoes were very good
Overall expensive for poor service and mediocre boil.
MS
Markia Schmelzer
Jan 16, 2026
4.0
Out of all the times I’ve been here tonight was the absolute worst service I’ve experienced. I got sat by my normal waitress and then a different waitress is the one serving our table after sitting for over 30 minutes and her taken a tables order who doesn’t even have all the members of their party. She come over and takes our order, nice gal but after the whole order she says I can’t do garlic butter we’re trying to save butter for the day. When asked to explain she says yeah we’re trying to conserve for the night. Not fully understanding she explains again and see the look of confusion on my face. I make adjustments to my order because we’re already seated and this is a normal spot for us. Their foods my favorite and the eggs are a must in any dish but mixing the medium and the garlic butter is a must. We will continue to On my way! Here but the level of service from the staff tonight was not the vibe. Thank goodness they have the normal gal working because honestly she holds it down. From someone who manages team members who do customer service tonight was a disappointment. Also because it was not as busy as I’ve seen it on a Friday night.
PJ
phil st j
Jan 14, 2026
5.0
Great fried green tomatoes. Also mushrooms.
Loved the poboys.
Daughters liked the $1 Monday oysters. We all loved the $1 Monday wings.
ET
Eduard Tsipan
Jan 8, 2026
4.0
I ordered the softshell crab, blackened shrimp, and seasoned fries via doordash.
Everything was delicious. For about $15, you only get one small soft shell crab though, which I think is a ripoff.
The shrimp came with dirty rice which was awesome.
What dining options are available near My Brother's Crawfish if I want to try other cuisines?
Nearby you can find V&A Sushi for sushi, Quan Linh Asian Bistro and Teo Bun Bo Hue for Vietnamese cuisine, Noodle Point and Good Taste Noodle House for Asian noodles, and Pot & Spicy for Pan Asian dishes.
Are there any bars or lounges near My Brother's Crawfish for a drink after dining?
Yes, Buddy's Lounge, a cocktail bar, is close by if you'd like to enjoy a drink after your meal.
Brand Certified Facts from My Brother's Crawfish
My Brother's Crawfish partners directly with Yext to publish this data from the brand's official system of record. Learn more about our data sources
Certified February 01, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: