East Side Mario's

Reviews

• PH

  P H

  3 days ago
  1.0
  Absolutely worst service in this place mid day. Server didn’t come attend to us and had major attitude. Took about 15 minutes to bring a glass of water. Pizza took 30mins and chicken tasted like it was just from the freezer. This has to be by far the worst place in Windsor.
• CC

  Coco Caltol

  Mar 15, 2026
  5.0
  The waiter last name was maddie was the best part of our experience. Super helpful, sweet, and very patient with our sons 12 yr birthday with his friends. Couldn't of asked for a more caring, fun waiter. Highly recommend. Food was 10/10 family dining.
• MD

  Marcus D

  Mar 15, 2026
  1.0
  Arrived today (Sunday at 12:30) and was seated quickly-table of four. Sat for well over thirty minutes with nobody coming to serve. Including our table there were four in the main dinning room. It wasn’t busy at this time. Lots of staff. One standing fanning herself, both of the cooks in the kitchen screwing around on their cell phones (no orders being cooked at that time). Manager on duty refunding an over charge to the table beside us and he didn’t even check on us after walking by three times to handle refund. Table that was there before us still had menus also and no drinks. Finally gave up and left. We should have already been done eating!!! Not sure why all of the servers running around couldn’t serve our table and the other two tables that sat waiting forever with no service. It was really sad. But hey, if you don’t need our business we will gladly go elsewhere. We got the point loud and clear!!
• AP

  Abigail Potter

  Mar 13, 2026
  5.0
  i would like to give a BIG shout to my server Tessa. She made me and my group feel like familia. I was in town, traveling from kentucky, and she provided the best service for me and my sister, Hannah, who she might remember. I told my friend Jude he’s GOTTA go to east side mario’s the next time he’s in Windsor. Anyway, thanks so much Tessa for a great dinner & service. Mangia mangia!
• JK

  Jill K

  Feb 27, 2026
  5.0
  We always love visiting East Side Mario’s, but tonight, Jamie went above and beyond making my nieces birthday dinner a special evening. She paid close attention to small details that really made a difference in our experience from the moment she greeted us, and it continued on our entire visit. Jamie, thank you for your spirit, kindness and excellent service. From my niece, Alice “Jamie was so nice and kind. I made her smile and she made me smile- she is so nice! I always love my visits here but this time I was really sad to leave. If I could I’d give Jamie a rating of a million out of 5 stars”

Frequently Asked Questions About East Side Mario's