Sandwich RestaurantFast Food RestaurantRestaurantTake Out RestaurantCatererSubway
Your local Stouffville Subway® Restaurant at 5812 Main St W brings bold new flavors and classic favorites to guests every day. Enjoy our famous Footlongs, 6" sandwiches, wraps, and salads, ordered quickly in the app or online, through convenient delivery, in-restaurant dining, or curbside pickup. We’re proud to offer a fresh alternative to typical fast food with fresh-cut veggies, tasty proteins, fresh-baked bread, and delicious cookies. We’re also here for your catering needs. All Subway® Restaurants are independently owned and operated by business owners who employ talented Sandwich Artists™.
Numerous reviews highlighted consistently poor customer service, including rude and dismissive staff, lack of accountability, and failure to follow instructions.
Food Quality
Many customers reported issues with food quality, including stale bread, insufficient toppings, and food safety concerns.
Order Accuracy
A significant number of reviews mentioned incorrect orders and missing items, leading to customer dissatisfaction.
Positive Experiences
Despite the negative feedback, some customers praised friendly staff and good service during their visits, indicating that experiences can vary.
DJ
Darshil Jani
Dec 29, 2025
5.0
I had a stellar experience at Subway today! The team was incredibly friendly and attentive, crafting my sandwich and Footlong Nachos exactly to my liking with a great attitude. Everything was remarkably fresh—from the perfectly toasted bread to the crisp, vibrant vegetables. Despite the lunch rush, the shop was spotless and the service was lightning-fast. With such a wide range of healthy and indulgent options, it’s obvious this team takes immense pride in their work. Subway truly nailed it—highly recommended!
BC
Becky Connell
Dec 18, 2025
1.0
This is the only Subway in Stouffville, and unfortunately it has consistently failed in customer service, food safety, and basic listening skills.
I no longer go in myself due to rude staff and sent my boyfriend instead. I was on the phone during the entire order and heard everything clearly.
Food safety concerns:
An employee previously scratched her head while making my sandwich and was not wearing a hair net, claiming they hadn’t had any for over a week. I had to ask for sandwich lining paper, and a dirty knife with dried red/BBQ-like sauce was used to cut my sub without being wiped.
Order completely ignored:
The order was repeated multiple times:
Minimal lettuce or spinach (got too much lettuce, barely any spinach)
Tomato, cucumber, onions (received only 4 slices of tomato and cucumber)
EXTRA EXTRA EXTRA pickles, hot peppers, jalapeños, and olives
“Extra extra extra” does NOT mean 4 pickle slices per side on a footlong. My boyfriend asked three times. The employee ignored the requests, added minimal toppings, closed the sandwich, and said it was already made.
When I called to complain, the employee lied, saying my boyfriend ordered “everything.” I heard the order myself. I was then told they were too busy to deal with it.
After spending $30 on two sandwiches, there was zero accountability or resolution. Yet they still prompt for tips while failing basic customer service and food safety standards.
If you can’t follow instructions or hygiene protocols, you shouldn’t be working in food service.
AD
Al DesRoches
Oct 29, 2025
1.0
Served by a lady who definitely had a very surly, condescending attitude. Rushed me through picking the vegetable add-ons even though there was no lineup.
I ordered a 6 inch assorted sub. The meat slices were so thin, I'm sure they've cut back on the thickness of their meat. Got home to find there was almost no sauce, sandwich was bone dry.
That crap for $10!! Never again.
SM
Sandy MacKenzie
Sep 18, 2025
1.0
I came in for a quick sandwich at quarter after 11 and the woman said I’ll be with you with in just a second but instead pulled out bread ready to be baked and put cheese on and then proceeded to pull out three more racks and ignored me all the while while she’s putting cheese on each of the loaves of bread. When asked to be served, she said wait I’m doing this. I found that rude condescending and explain to her that I feel that I’m more important than that and she did nothing to satisfy me. I left without buying and went to Mr. sub instead, I will never return to Subway as there are plenty of other options where I will be treated better.
MM
Missy
Sep 8, 2025
1.0
I ordered a sub on Subway App. When I got there, this grumpy old South Asian woman was making my sub. I asked for “more” pickles on the app, but she only gave me a little so I asked her for more. No acknowledgment, only a grunt. When I was getting my sandwich, she just threw it to me on the counter without saying thank you or anything. The worst customer service I received EVER at Subway. Do NOT recommend coming here.
Where is the Subway restaurant located in Stouffville?
The Subway restaurant is located at 5812 Main St W, Stouffville, ON, L4A 2S9, Canada.
What are the operating hours of the Subway at 5812 Main St W?
The restaurant is open Monday to Friday from 8:00 AM to 11:00 PM, Saturday from 9:00 AM to 11:00 PM, and Sunday from 9:00 AM to 10:00 PM.
Does Subway at this location offer pickup and delivery services?
Yes, they offer curbside pickup and convenient delivery options, along with in-restaurant dining.
What types of meals are served at this Subway restaurant?
They serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
Can I view the menu for this Subway online?
Yes, you can see the menu and order online at https://subway.com/en-ca/restaurant/7509-0/menu.
What payment options are accepted at the Subway on Main St W?
They accept American Express, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa.
Does Subway provide catering services at this location?
Yes, catering services are available to meet your needs.
Are there any other dining options near the Subway at 5812 Main St W?
Yes, nearby dining options include Vi Pei Bistro - Stouffville, Kato Sushi, and ZEAL Burgers, which offer bistro, Japanese, sushi, and burger cuisines respectively.
What nearby automotive services are available close to this Subway location?
Nearby you can find Leggat Stouffville Ford, Bill Houston Ford, and Bruce's Auto Service Repair for car sales, leasing, and repairs.
Are there financial services near the Subway at Main St W?
Yes, nearby financial services include Burgundy Investment Group and Janet Sun - BMO Financial Planner, as well as banking services from TD Canada Trust Branch & ATM.