Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• TS

  Taylor Smith

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Total 5 Star, great consistent food, great staff!
• MT

  More Truth

  Feb 14, 2026
  1.0
  Bunch of dishonest people working at papa John's pizzas. I went there yesterday to buy a thin crust medium hawaiian pizza the lying dishonest boy says they dont sell thin crust pizza in medium. Then he went a head and over charge me for a large pizza, I also saw the lady employee not wearing gloves and be making people pizza, nasty and disgusted people. Asking for my receipt yet didnt receive none because the guy knows he is crook. Charging me for extra toppings pepper and seasoning that I didnt order, I just realize it on the box when I get home. Papa John's pizza is hiring crooks to represent them.
• AT

  Anthony Trejo

  Feb 7, 2026
  1.0
  Really disappointed with the customer service at Papa John’s in Milton. When I went to pick up my pizza, the woman at the front desk clearly saw me but didn’t acknowledge me at all. She kept doing other things and never asked if I was there to pick up or order. I stood there for about 10 minutes while two other customers walked in. An employee then came to the register and immediately asked the person who just walked in if they were there for pickup, completely ignoring me even though I was there first. When I pointed out that I had been waiting, there was no apology or acknowledgment. Turns out my pizza had been ready the whole time—it took him 20 seconds to grab it. This is basic customer service. They need to respect customers, acknowledge people when they walk in, and treat everyone fairly. I hope management improves the customer experience here.
• AH

  Alexander Hogan

  Jan 23, 2026
  1.0
  Can’t fulfill orders on Uber. Should probably put yourself as closed rather than canceling orders.
• GW

  George western

  Jan 23, 2026
  5.0
  Great pizza. Best ever pizza I had

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza