East Side Mario's

Reviews

• ST

  sue thiessen

  1 day ago
  1.0
  I got the sampler with chicken parm, Alfredo and the tiniest piece of lasagna I have ever seen in my life. Absolutely dry and soooooo tasteless. I got a berry glass of sangria that was so incredibly sour. My husband's Hells kitchen chicken had no sauce what so ever. They were very busy ... maybe something was going on in the kitchen, I don't know. Our waiter was a super nice young man. We wasted $80 in my opinion. Won't be back.
• AM

  Ashley M

  1 day ago
  1.0
  Really regret coming here. I really don’t understand the 5 star reviews as this place is a disgrace to Italian cuisine. The food tasted like it came out of a can or a box. I had the chicken Parmesan and I left feeling disgusted. Paid extra for the all you can eat soup, bread, and salad during lunch. But because the food was so terrible, it was more like “all I can not eat”. Never again will I step foot in this “restaurant”. For two people who each got an item from the lunch menu plus the AYCE soup, bread, and salad, and waters to drink it came to over $55. Extremely overpriced for something I wouldn’t even give my dog.
• TM

  Taylor Millar

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Had a lovely dinner here the other day, our server Taylor was one of the best waitresses I've ever had! She was quick to provide more bread, soup and salad, super friendly and a hard worker. The soup, salad and bread were excellent and my husband enjoyed his spicy sausage pasta dish. The chicken alfredo was very bland. Had almost no flavour. I added a good amount of salt and pepper and it did help make it editable but I wouldn't order it again. We will definitely be back!
• JB

  Jeanine Bolohan

  Jan 4, 2026
  4.0
  Ashley was sooo patient with me when I was giving a very confusing explanation for a drink. Great server personality and so attentive. I will say that I called night before to reserve table for 10 at 4pm. The gentlemen made sure that I knew I was calling the Wonderland location. When we arrived the hostess had no record or notice of our reservation. The hostess was immediately helpful...thank goodness it was not a busy time and table was ready right away.
• KP

  Kyle Private

  Jan 1, 2026
  2.0
  The servers are great. No complaints with them. However the food is cheap garbage. I ordered spaghetti and meatballs and ceasar salad. Only good part was the free bread and the glass of coke I ordered. The spaghetti noodles was overcooked and unsalted so it tasted very soft, watery and bland. The sauce you can get from a grocery store, the meatballs tasted like ground beef and that's it, no other flavor. The ceasar salad is sharp and tangy, almost sour like they added a lot of lemon on it. Not my ideal taste for a ceasar salad but maybe it works for other people. Overall this isnt real Italian food, it's very americanized and tasted like fast food instead of a sit down restaurant. I can tell ingredients are being skipped on and to me it felt very rushed. Overall the vibe in the restaurant is typical of what you would get at chucks roadhouse or kelseys so nothing really unique except the posters on the wall are in italian. I honestly can make better at home for less.

Frequently Asked Questions About East Side Mario's