Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• HT

  Hana Teresha

  Mar 24, 2026
  1.0
  I ordered extra Canadian Bacan with Extra Bacon. BUT NO A SINGLE BACON HERE!!!
• AW

  Alex Wiersma

  Mar 22, 2026
  5.0
  Accidentally ordered pizza 1 minute before closing because i read the hours of the wrong location. They still made the pizza! I appreciate it and am very sorry to the employees.
• NA

  Noli Aromin

  Mar 15, 2026
  3.0
  The pizza is good,one thing I've observed,the 2 male staff at the kitchen has full beard and not wearing a hair net to cover the beard. Food preparation safety issue..
• MT

  Mike Tazzeo

  Mar 7, 2026
  3.0
  Tried Papa Johns on Fennell in Hamilton and it was a bit of a mixed experience overall. The wings were actually quite good, although I wish there were more options that weren’t baked. They came with a pretty generic dipping sauce on the side. We ordered a New York style pizza. The toppings were decent, but the crust was disappointing — it had a bit of a cardboard-like texture. Ironically, it seemed better the next day, maybe because the sauce had a chance to add a little moisture to the crust. One thing I did appreciate was the anchovies on the side — they were a good variety and a nice option to have. Overall it was okay, but a bit on the pricey side… though honestly that seems to be the case everywhere these days.
• AZ

  A Z

  Mar 6, 2026
  5.0
  Imo best pizza shop. Very consistent and always tasty! The sauce is sweet but not to sweet, the cheese is always well all over the pizza, toppings are good ( wouldnt mind a bit more sometimes a little light ). I wish they would get a new pizza cutter; often times I'm having to cut it over again at home! :(