Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• MT

  Mike Tazzeo

  6 days ago
  3.0
  Tried Papa Johns on Fennell in Hamilton and it was a bit of a mixed experience overall. The wings were actually quite good, although I wish there were more options that weren’t baked. They came with a pretty generic dipping sauce on the side. We ordered a New York style pizza. The toppings were decent, but the crust was disappointing — it had a bit of a cardboard-like texture. Ironically, it seemed better the next day, maybe because the sauce had a chance to add a little moisture to the crust. One thing I did appreciate was the anchovies on the side — they were a good variety and a nice option to have. Overall it was okay, but a bit on the pricey side… though honestly that seems to be the case everywhere these days.
• AZ

  A Z

  Mar 6, 2026
  5.0
  Imo best pizza shop. Very consistent and always tasty! The sauce is sweet but not to sweet, the cheese is always well all over the pizza, toppings are good ( wouldnt mind a bit more sometimes a little light ). I wish they would get a new pizza cutter; often times I'm having to cut it over again at home! :(
• AS

  Ayaan Sharma

  Jan 29, 2026
  5.0
  I just picked up cheese sticks and chicken wings (dips on side) and it was the most delicious decision! Food was so fresh and very good quality of chicken wings! The staff was especially so kind and friendly and suggested really good options for future! Anmol did a fantastic job with my order! Will def go here again! :)
• AS

  Avinash Singh

  Jan 13, 2026
  4.0
  Ordering ahead is always a great option. The staff are friendly each time I have been to pick up a carryout. My kids like Papa Johns pizza so routinely order from this location. Check for promotions and flyers as you will usually get a discount. If you s use the Papa Johns app you will get quick cash back for your following order or collect for a few months. Applying an additional 2-6$ off the final order is always nice to experience. Couple time pizza was well done not by request so 4/5.
• DP

  DA P

  Dec 26, 2025
  5.0
  We’ve tried Pizza Store 3–4 times and it’s been consistently good. The beef is flavorful, and the sauces really stand out—especially the butter chicken sauce. The service is excellent, and Anmol is always friendly and helpful.