Customers frequently praised the friendly and attentive service from staff, particularly highlighting individual servers like Rebecca and Kenya.
Food Quality
While many reviews noted good food and generous portions, there were complaints about inconsistent quality, including issues with freshness and taste.
Wait Times
Numerous customers expressed frustration with slow service and long wait times for food and drinks, impacting their overall dining experience.
Cleanliness
Some reviews mentioned cleanliness issues, particularly with the bathrooms, which detracted from the dining experience.
Menu Variety
Customers noted a reduction in menu options and expressed disappointment over the lack of traditional dishes that were previously offered.
JJ
Jaydensantiagoo
Oct 10, 2025
5.0
Had a dinner with my family service was very good. Our server Alliyah was very nice very helpful!!
TS
Tom da Silva
Sep 15, 2025
1.0
This location has been Eataly for 2 years. Google please change the status from "temporarily closed" to permanent, thank you!
SW
Siobhan Wach
Aug 18, 2019
2.0
Not a great experience. Prices high for subpar food. Dry chicken burger, paid 3$ extra for sweet potato fries and about 2/3 of the small fry container was empty.
Paid 10.99 for kids salmon and it was a tiny 2oz piece and very dry.
Server was unattentive and unfriendly. We asked for our bill early and she forgot us completely after bringing it and we had to ask the manager for it. Only bonus is that it has large alcoholic beverages so maybe they want to get you drunk to ignore the bland over priced food. Won't be returning.
Frequently Asked Questions About Pickle Barrel - PERMANENTLY CLOSED
Why am I not able to book a reservation online?
The majority of our tables are available for walk-ins. Due to high business volumes requests may not be granted on weekend (Fri-Sun), please call the restaurant directly.
Do you offer set-menus?
Yes! We offer group menus or you are more than welcome to order off of our restaurant menu. To View group menus, please visit our website https://picklebarrel.ca/reservations-group-bookings/
Is Pickle Barrel still open for dining?
Pickle Barrel is permanently closed and not currently open for dining or any services.
Did Pickle Barrel accept reservations when it was open?
Yes, Pickle Barrel accepted reservations.
What were the brunch hours at Pickle Barrel?
Brunch was served from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM on weekdays and 10:00 AM to 3:00 PM on weekends before closing.
What meal services did Pickle Barrel offer?
Pickle Barrel served brunch, lunch, and dinner.
What types of payment were accepted at Pickle Barrel?
Pickle Barrel accepted American Express, Cash, Mastercard, and Visa.
Did Pickle Barrel offer takeout and delivery services?
Delivery was available from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM on weekdays and Sundays, and extended to 10:00 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Where was Pickle Barrel located?
Pickle Barrel was located at 25 The West Mall, Etobicoke, ON, M9C 1B8, Canada.
Are there any nearby dining options close to where Pickle Barrel was located?
Nearby dining options include Poulet Rouge, Amaya Sherway (Indian restaurant), Big Smoke Burger, McDonald's, and JOEY SHERWAY bar and restaurant, which customers might visit before or after their meal.
What nearby stores can customers visit near the former Pickle Barrel location?
Customers can visit stores like American Eagle Outfitters, Michael Kors, Banana Republic, and Gap in the nearby Sherway Gardens shopping area.