The Burger's Priest

Reviews

• MB

  Mark Bocock

  2 days ago
  5.0
  I love the Burger's Priest! Amazing burger choices and always consistent with quality. I prefer the poutine but the stern fries are great as well. If I'm starving I get the Vatican burger but I usually just get the priest...the cheesy, peppery mushroom center makes this burger my go-to. Gluten options as well as they have gluten free buns. My wife has ciliac and she's never been gluten'd here. Highly recommended. Oh, and you know it's amazing bc this is their second Barrie location so they must be doing something right. Highly recommended.
• AA

  Anna13

  3 days ago
  1.0
  gross and cheap toppings. mcdonalds is better then what i had today on april 9th 1145 am. the amount of grease was not needed at all. i cannot stand it when companies charge for premium and give you very little in return. the review about the old lettuce is accurate i had to take mine off too. tomatoes are the tiniest. bacon nonexistent and not cooked properly. the bun taste weird. meat is slimy. everything about this order is digusting and i am sick to my tummy after eating it. waste of money total rip off. i threw most of it away. never again.
• AM

  Amanda McCormick

  5 days ago
  4.0
  We were 3 people and ordered 2 bacon cheese burgers and an impossible burger. And 3 fries Spent $57 It was our first time to this location we were excited as we live north of Barrie. The friendliness and speed of service was excellent 5/5. Communication was less as the fries were shoestring fries and were crispy, with a sweet note. Not sure where the sweet was coming from. I usually love the fries but these were not good at all 1/5. I did call the restaurant as I wasn’t sure if this was a change for burger priest as a whole or just this location. She said it was an error. We were offered fresh fries with proper cut but we were eating on the road and live outside of area. Since they are not the right cut it would have been appropriate to ask if we were okay with them thin cut before serving. If it’s not as described on the menu they should not be served. The manager offer free fries at another visit. I will review again at a later time. The hamburger with bacon were super greasy compared to other location 3.5/5. Impossible burger was 4/5. Overall all the burgers seemed under seasoned. And toppings cold to warm burger. I will try again, and review but based solely off of the visit the food was underwhelming
• RM

  Robert McCord

  Apr 5, 2026
  5.0
  Really enjoyed The High Priest, their take on 2 all beef patties, special sauce, lettuce, cheese, pickles, onions on fresh yummy bun. I tried some of my wife's Classic Chicken also and it was really good too, fries were fresh and tasty and our server Harneet was great. Excellent meal, best burger I've had in awhile.
• DF

  Debbie Fletcher

  Apr 4, 2026
  5.0
  We decided to try the Burger’s Priest for the first time ever. We went to the Bayfield Street location since it is very close to where we live. The location was clean, the service was great and the food was fantastic!! We ordered the High Priest combo with fries and the Classic Chicken Sandwich combo with fries. We were extremely pleased with the taste and temperature of the food. Everything was hot, fresh, and cooked perfectly!! The fries were awesome!! The High Priest tasted like a Big Mac but, WAY better😋 The Chicken sandwich tasted like Mary Brown’s but WAY better!! The fries were abundant, crispy and hot..yum!! In fact, there were so many we couldn’t finish them!! This never happens!! We did find it was a little expensive but, what isn’t anymore?!!! Thanks to Harneet, Bryan and others for the excellent food and fast and friendly service!! We will definitely be returning😊

Frequently Asked Questions About The Burger's Priest