New York Bagel Cafe

4.5
732 reviews
Get DirectionsCallWebsite

Business Details

3723 S Peoria Ave, Tulsa, OK
74105, United States
(918) 743-7400
https://newyorkbageltulsa.com/nybcbrookside

About

Bagel Shop

Details

  • DeliveryAvailable
  • TakeoutAvailable
  • Curbside pickupAvailable

Location

New York Bagel Cafe
3723 S Peoria Ave, Tulsa, OK
74105, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.5
732 reviews
5 stars
540
4 stars
109
3 stars
33
2 stars
20
1 star
30

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Bagel Quality

Customers have mixed opinions on the bagels, with some praising their authenticity and taste, while others report stale or poorly made bagels.

Service Issues

Numerous reviews highlight inconsistent service, including order mistakes and unprofessional behavior from staff.

Atmosphere

The shop is generally described as having a pleasant atmosphere, with many customers enjoying the cozy seating and outdoor options.

Customer Loyalty

Despite some negative experiences, many customers express a strong loyalty to the business, often returning for their favorite bagels.
  • BB
    Bar
    4 days ago
    1.0
    I've been going to this place for years! It has also been my go to for a quick breakfast or brunch on the road. This morning unfortunately my chicken Caesar bagel order was made with very brown romaine lettuce and was literally drenched in dressing and the chicken tasted like it had been sitting out. I also ordered a cookie that tasted mostly like flour and was hard as a rock. My chai was basically milk with a dash of chai. So disappointing. It will be awhile before I go back. Very lackluster.
  • CJ
    Caroline Jones
    Dec 30, 2025
    5.0
    Great bagels. Nowhere comparable in town, anyone from here knows it. This isn’t like a nice breakfast place. It’s a bagel place plain and simple. The bagels are the same as/better than some in nyc.
  • OB
    Olivia Burrus
    Dec 30, 2025
    1.0
    I prefer the one on 71st and Yale. I ordered in the app to have the order made at a slightly later time so it would be done when I got to Tulsa (about 30 minutes later). They made it immediately so it was cold when I got there and it was not the right order. The bagel they did give me was okay.
  • AY
    Allison Young
    Dec 23, 2025
    1.0
    My bagel had fuzz on it, it was stale, and it had half the normal amount of cream cheese. My chai was all milk, and my boyfriend got a plain coffee instead of what he ordered. And the lady in the drive through was not friendly. Normally we have no problems but if this is the new standard, we will not be coming back.
  • BB
    Benjamin Brown
    Nov 23, 2025
    5.0
    Outstanding!
Read more reviews on Google

Frequently Asked Questions About New York Bagel Cafe

What are the standard operating hours of New York Bagel Cafe?

New York Bagel Cafe is open from 6:00 AM to 3:00 PM Monday through Saturday, and from 7:00 AM to 3:00 PM on Sundays.

Does New York Bagel Cafe offer delivery and in-store pickup services?

Yes, New York Bagel Cafe offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.