Captain John's, McAlester

Reviews

• JD

  Jon Diaz

  6 days ago
  4.0
  Ice cold Yuengling on tap, and a delicious catfish platter with two sides for only $12.99. Really enjoyed this meal!
• RL

  Robert Long

  Feb 18, 2026
  1.0
  Had had lunch thee daily since covid, plus health issues I have but was barred for a very untrue allegation from a front hostess that I had caught keeping tip money for another hostess, so for spite tells her mommy a lie that was totally false to top manager who didn't bother to ask me about, just barred me.Since covid and eating there daily I've paid over 60 thousand dollars tips and price of food to hostesses and servers only to be kicked under the bus for jealous hostess who got caught taking money that wasn't hers. Miss some good friend servers and food but upper management is very disappointing. Karma. B. L.
• DG

  Debbie Goines

  Feb 17, 2026
  5.0
  Heard good things about this place so drove an hour and 45 minutes to ck it out. It was really good. Lots of choices and very reasonable prices. I highly recommend if ur in the area.
• SQ

  Sauncie Quillin

  Feb 9, 2026
  5.0
  The meal itself was great. I would’ve liked to had two rolls, not one. The other thing which is just my opinion I don’t think that you should be putting a tip on a takeout order, i’m not sitting at a table someone coming and waiting on me but everything else was great
• DC

  Daniel Caldwell

  Feb 2, 2026
  4.0
  Have ate here several times. Today was the first time I was disappointed. Got the shrimp boil. This was not a boil. Just some unseasoned shrimp put in a bowl. Didn’t even get my hands messy. So just a word of advice. Order anything, but the boil