Business Details
About
Seafood Restaurant
Details
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- Curbside pickupAvailable
Location
Captain John's, McAlester
1216 S George Nigh Expy D, McAlester, OK
74501, United States
Hours
Reviews
4.6
2,168 reviews
5 stars
1,674
4 stars
316
3 stars
75
2 stars
41
1 star
62
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Customers consistently praised the food for being delicious, with standout dishes like catfish, gator bites, and steaks.
Service
The service received high marks for being friendly, attentive, and accommodating, enhancing the overall dining experience.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is noted for its welcoming and pleasant atmosphere, making it a favorite stop for travelers.
Hygiene Concerns
Some customers raised concerns about cleanliness and food safety, with reports of food poisoning and misleading menu items.
Reservation Issues
Several reviews mentioned long wait times for seating and issues with reservations, indicating a need for better management during busy periods.
- WWWyle2 days ago5.0The best mac and cheese in the world
- DHDena Herte3 days ago5.0Whitney R was my server and she did an amazing job! Brought me extra rolls and vinegar. The broccoli was soooooo good. Thank you ! 🤩👍💕🍽️🍞
- AGAlexander GreinDec 30, 20251.0Took my wife for her birthday and told them it was her birthday watched them sing to two other people with 2 different servers and when we got our bill I asked and they said we'll you already paid id have to ring you up again and I can't do that it left a bad taste in my mouth and ruined the rest of my night we ain't be returning
- JMJeff MainsDec 29, 20254.0This place makes our restaurant short lists on trips from Texas to Oklahoma. Food is good, service is great, and wait timea are usually decent. Fish is our go to and with a name like Captain, how could you go wrong?
- JWJohn WilliamsDec 16, 20255.0Captain John's is one of the best fish and places in Southern Oklahoma. Food quality and facility is top notch. Cannot wait till my next visit.