Numerous reviews highlighted slow service, with many customers experiencing long wait times for food and drinks, and some reporting rude or inattentive staff.
Food Quality
Feedback on food quality was mixed; while some enjoyed the wings and burgers, many reported cold food, incorrect orders, and poor preparation.
Cleanliness Concerns
Several customers noted cleanliness issues, including dirty tables, floors, and restrooms, which detracted from their dining experience.
Positive Staff Experiences
A few reviews praised specific staff members for their excellent service, indicating that there are capable employees who can enhance the customer experience.
Delivery Problems
Many customers expressed frustration with delivery orders, citing missing items, cold food, and long wait times.
TT
Timothy Tedeschi
3 days ago
2.0
Twice in a row now our order has been messed up. The first time, the food was cold, and an entire item was left out of our order. They offered us coupons, which we picked up, and used again this time, but the employees were hesitant to accept it. This time, they left out an item we'd paid an upcharge for. Both times, the wings were not sauced all the way and had bare spots. Also, upon placing the order over the phone, and picking up the order, employees were quite rude. I wouldn't mind if they were neutral or just mildly polite, but they were blatantly rude. We will not plan to order from this location again--we will try out the Mentor location instead.
ET
Ethan Tolentino
Nov 11, 2025
1.0
Stood in lobby for 15 minutes waiting to be seated multiple other people asked why there was nobody upfront nobody ever came up and workers were walking around doing nothing
BP
Beverly Puccini
Nov 7, 2025
1.0
Absolutely horrible service- waited for our pick up order for over an hour.
KC
Kenneth Crockett
Nov 7, 2025
1.0
WARNING - do NOT recommend placing a pickup order from this BWW!! Pickup time for my order was 6:20p and going on 7p with no food in sight.
Restaurant has a max of 10 patrons (mostly at the bar) and there’s only one findable employee every 10-15mins.
If I hadn’t already paid for my order I’da left long ago, and in fact I may still leave
JS
Jenna Stigall
Oct 20, 2025
1.0
I tried to order food for delivery, against my better judgment. Multiple times in the past, my orders have been delivered cold, items missing, or late. People make mistakes, and I know I am not right around the corner, but I was hoping to give it another shot. I placed my order at 6:40. I received a text that the order was placed and expected to arrive at 7:05. Then, at 7:50, on the tracker I see it has changed to 8:15. After contacting my dasher, I am told my order was given away to someone else. My order was canceled and now it is 8:30 and I have no dinner. This is the last time I give this location a chance.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in Willoughby specialize in?
Buffalo Wild Wings offers award-winning Buffalo, New York-style wings with 26 different sauces and seasonings to choose from.
What are the operating hours for Buffalo Wild Wings in Willoughby?
The restaurant is open from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM on Monday, Wednesday, and Sunday; and from 11:00 AM to midnight on Tuesday, Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in Willoughby?
It is located at 36455 Euclid Avenue, Willoughby, OH 44094.
How can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Willoughby by phone?
You can reach Buffalo Wild Wings by calling +1 440-527-8081.
Is Buffalo Wild Wings in Willoughby currently open?
Yes, the Buffalo Wild Wings location in Willoughby is currently open.
What categories best describe Buffalo Wild Wings in Willoughby?
Buffalo Wild Wings is categorized as a Chicken Wings Restaurant, Sports Bar, Restaurant, and Takeout restaurant.
Are there any Mexican restaurants near Buffalo Wild Wings in Willoughby?
Yes, Don Pablo's and Cocos Locos Willoughby are Mexican restaurants located nearby, offering an alternative dining option if you're in the area.
What nearby places can customers visit after enjoying Buffalo Wild Wings?
Customers might visit PetSmart for pet supplies, or relax at Candy Cloud - Willoughby, a coffee shop with smoothies and bubble tea.
Are there other eateries close to Buffalo Wild Wings in Willoughby?
Yes, nearby options include Jersey Mike's Subs, Marco's Pizza, Gril Craft BBQ, and Penn Station East Coast Subs, offering a variety of food choices.
Can I find services like hair salons or banks near Buffalo Wild Wings in Willoughby?
Yes, Great Clips and Leaf's Hair Lounge offer beauty services nearby, and Huntington Bank is available for banking needs close to Buffalo Wild Wings.