Hindsight Pizza (Chicken - Pizza - Pasta)

Reviews

• PS

  Priestess Kikyo Sama

  1 day ago
  3.0
  I actually eat here pretty much every week. The pizza and burgers are usually delicious. I'd been wanting to try the muddy burger for a while. But I was really disappointed. It was dry, the meat was too thick, it wasn't like a smashburger, no hint of the cream cheese and barely any bbq and smash sauce. Nobody likes a dry patty. I might order other stuff but yeah that burger was a big letdown. It really needs improvement.
• DQ

  David Quiroga

  1 day ago
  4.0
  I really want to give 5 stars because the pizza tasted great. the tuesday half off deal is amazing. however, i picked a specialty pizza and asked for no black olives or ham. and they missed. i was able to pick them off with out changing much but they were still there. i double checked my order and the receipt and both showed no black olives and no ham. other than that, was prepared fast and still hot when got home. I will be going back.
• TB

  Tom BranNA

  Apr 19, 2026
  5.0
  2nd or 3rd time picking up order. Clean counter area. Will have to try eating in sometime. Menu has quite a variety.
• MS

  Mary Schira

  Apr 18, 2026
  5.0
  Love their pickle bread and the Porky Pickle pizza! Food is always consistently delicious. Today we placed a large order for 12 people and everything was prepared perfectly
• SB

  Si-Si Bostic

  Apr 14, 2026
  1.0
  I’ve really enjoyed ordering from here over the past couple of weeks—especially during the daytime. The flavors have been great, and it quickly became my go-to pizza spot. However, my most recent order was disappointing. I ordered at night and got the Philly and Alfredo pizzas, and they weren’t consistent with what I’ve had before. I specifically requested the “Hindsway” crust toppers, but only received garlic and parmesan instead of the usual Cajun/Italian seasoning. Additionally, the Alfredo pizza was burnt and very dry, which made it hard to enjoy. I’m hoping this was just an off night, because I’ve had great experiences before. I’d appreciate better consistency going forward.