Home Slice Pizza

Reviews

• MR

  Michael Rys

  2 days ago
  5.0
  The only thing I regret about Homeslice is waiting so long to try it. Nice vibes in the cozy old school bar/dining room area. Killer beer selection and a pizza menu to satisfy all tastes. I went for the carnivore pizza and an Italian salad. The salad is big enough to share with three or four people if you want an appetizer. The pizza came out pretty quickly too. Gorgeous looking,piping hot steam coming off it and cut in nice size pieces. Snappy thin crust not drowning in sauce and plentiful toppings all cooked to well done perfection. I now have two favorite pizza places in Toledo.Looking forward to trying more thier pizza creations.
• PF

  ProMedica FCU

  3 days ago
  5.0
  The Best Pizza in Toledo. My first time and it won’t be my last. As good as it gets!
• JA

  Joshua Amborski

  4 days ago
  2.0
  We like the location of this restaurant, but today we ordered online for pickup. I showed up when the app told me to show up (20 min after ordering). They hadnt even printed my ticket out yet. They said it would take them 8 min to make my cheesy bread with garlic. So I waited while my beer got warm at the brewery across the street just for them to give me a cold cheesy bread with no garlic on it. I walked back over and they gave me the correct bread with garlic. The bread was doughy and undercooked. Just a terrible experience on a relatively quiet saturday downtown.
• DR

  Dustin Reed

  Jan 31, 2026
  5.0
  Embarrassinly I have lived in the Toledo area most of my adult life and I have only had home slice once before I gave it another try today. What a mistake! Home slice is such a charming place with the best pizza in Toledo! The pie has such a tasty crunchy crust and the ingredients are top notch. The slice has no flop and it's cooked to perfection. We also got the home slice bread which was so good as well! Home slice will for now on be part of pizza stops in the area. Give them a try you won't be disappointed!
• SM

  Sabrina McCloskey

  Jan 30, 2026
  1.0
  After reading the reviews we choose to order here while in town. We did delivery and I’ll say it was quick which was nice . However, that’s where the food ended . The pizza did not look like what we saw in reviews. I wish I had pictures but we were hungry so we dove in. There was very little to no cheese on 2 of the 4 pizzas. We got the mashed potatoes pizza but didn’t get the sour cream . You could taste some potato but that was about it. The chicken bacon ranch pizza had rubber chicken and no ranch and very little cheese . The meat pizza had alot of meat at least. Honestly we ate because we were starving but had we not been I would have gotten something else. I sent in a review, did a survey, asked for follow up and got none. Basically ignored.