Many customers reported long wait times for food and poor service, with some servers being inattentive or dismissive.
Food Quality
The quality of food has been inconsistent, with complaints about cold, overcooked, or improperly prepared items.
Management Concerns
Several reviews highlighted issues with management, including poor communication and lack of accountability for mistakes.
Positive Staff Experiences
Despite the issues, some customers praised specific servers for their excellent service and attentiveness.
Pricing Concerns
Customers expressed dissatisfaction with rising prices and perceived value, particularly regarding portion sizes and food quality.
TW
tony wehbe
Nov 17, 2025
5.0
Good food, especially salads. Highly recommend this chicken salad…
LS
Luke Smigielski
Nov 11, 2025
1.0
One hour wait time for some dried up wings that came literally cold from the kitchen. Terrible.
AM
Amanda Marchand
Nov 9, 2025
1.0
I’m honestly not sure why we gave this place another try. This is the second disappointing experience within about a month.
We placed our order at 1:33 PM (receipt shows 1:35 PM) and were given a pickup time of 1:50 PM. We arrived right at 1:50 PM and the food wasn’t ready. We sat and waited. The waiter mentioned they were “just waiting on the chicken sandwich.” During the next 30 minutes, four other groups came in after us, and when the food finally came out, the waiter brought out food for all five groups at the same time.
Our order wasn’t actually ready until 2:18 PM. We got home at 2:23 PM and everything was cold—not warm, not room temperature, but cold. On top of that, the food is not cheap. For example, the fried pickles are $9.50, and the ticket for them was printed at 1:42 PM—so they sat for quite a while. We literally counted nine pickles.
We used to really enjoy this place (at least a year ago), but after two back-to-back bad experiences a month apart, we’re done. And it’s not like we ordered anything complicated: fried pickles, fries, a chicken sandwich, chicken wrap, and loaded tots—$50+ total.
There were plenty of staff visible and chatting, so I’m unsure why the delays and poor quality happened.
Is this the normal experience now? Because it definitely didn’t used to be.
TR
Tess Russell
Oct 14, 2025
1.0
my experience tonight was awful. the atmosphere of the restaurant is always the same so i’ll give them that, but everything else was horrible. Our waitress introduced herself (Grace) and was very pleasant at first. As we started to put our order of boneless wings in, she spoke up and said they had a deal of buy one get half off, so of course we wanted to do that! This explanation was given to us with no specification that boneless wings were not included. our food was brought over and we said it wasn’t right and the food runner was very kind but our waitress couldn’t have cared less. we waited half an hour already, just to get the wrong food and then she said “sorry for not being more specific” and that was that. no coupon, not taken off the bill, nothing. she hardly spoke to us, acknowledged that it was HER mistake. we are typically very understanding when things like this happen, as I work in the restaurant industry. this situation was handled so poorly and if they expect people to keep coming back after being treated with disrespect, they are crazy.
TT
Toledo
Oct 11, 2025
3.0
Over an hour wait for food on a Friday night. No compensation or apologies from staff or management. No follow up after food was delivered.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What are the operating hours of Buffalo Wild Wings in Toledo, OH?
Buffalo Wild Wings in Toledo is open Monday through Thursday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, Fridays until midnight, and on weekends with extended hours including late night on Saturday and Sunday.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in Toledo?
It is located at 6710 West Central Avenue, Toledo, OH 43617, United States.
What kind of food does Buffalo Wild Wings offer?
Buffalo Wild Wings offers award-winning Buffalo, New York-style chicken wings with a choice of 26 different sauces and seasonings.
How can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Toledo?
You can reach them by phone at +1 419-843-2400.
Does Buffalo Wild Wings have an online presence where I can learn more?
Yes, you can visit their official webpage for this location at https://www.buffalowildwings.com/locations/us/oh/toledo/6710-west-central-avenue/sports-bar-414/
Is Buffalo Wild Wings in Toledo considered a sports bar?
Yes, it is categorized as both a sports bar and a chicken wings restaurant, making it a great place to enjoy wings while watching sports.
What dessert options are available near Buffalo Wild Wings on West Central Avenue?
Crumbl Cookies and Crumbl - Sylvania are nearby dessert places where you can enjoy cookies and sweet treats before or after your visit.
Are there other dining options close to Buffalo Wild Wings in Toledo?
Yes, nearby options include Tiger Bakery & Deli for Lebanese and Mediterranean cuisine, Amie's Pizza Factory for Italian and pizza, and Jersey Mike's Subs for sandwiches and fast food.
What entertainment or recreational places are near Buffalo Wild Wings in Toledo?
The Sandbox for Kids is a nearby playground and recreation venue, making it convenient for families to visit before or after dining at Buffalo Wild Wings.
How can nearby stores enhance my visit to Buffalo Wild Wings?
Nearby stores like Verizon and Sherwin-Williams allow you to handle errands such as mobile needs or home supplies, making a visit to the area more convenient.