Jimmy John's

Reviews

• NH

  Nairika Hough

  Jan 2, 2026
  1.0
  Went in to put in an order and had to walk out because the girl behind the counter making food was SOOO sick! Making sandwiches while sniffling, coughing, and literally saying how bad her head hurt! I felt terrible for her but im not going to eat food made by someone who is obviously very visibly ill. Wasn't wearing a mask, just gloves. You should never have someone whose that sick working with food. So not okay.
• CD

  Clarrissa Dillon

  Nov 29, 2025
  1.0
  Delivered the wrong sandwich, called asked for the right one, the lady on the phone said okay and hung up .. 30 minutes later nothing had been delivered, I called them and they said they never made it and didn’t plan on it when I said that’s awful service I hate to leave a bad review but this really calls for it so other people know about the awful customer service at the pickerington location, the manager responded “oh well we get bad reviews everyday”..
• EH

  E Hisey

  Nov 27, 2025
  5.0
  Delicious and you can get their gift cards here
• FE

  Fire Elekes

  Nov 25, 2025
  5.0
  Jillian and the manager at this Pickerington location are incredible- exceptional customer service so helpful, professional and easy to work with! Appreciate you both so much for going out of your way!
• JS

  Jennifer Starr

  Nov 14, 2025
  5.0
  I don’t know the name of the closer tonight but he was amazing. We walked in at closing time and he made he had the same attitude he would have with the 1st customer of the day. Polite the place was clean food was made and I was really impressed - good work!!!!!