Overall, customers praised the food for its flavor and freshness, with many highlighting specific dishes like tacos and enchiladas as favorites.
Service
Service received mixed reviews; while many customers appreciated the friendly and attentive staff, others reported issues with order accuracy and slow service.
Value
Some customers felt the prices were high for the portion sizes and quality, with complaints about watered-down drinks and additional charges.
Consistency
Several reviews noted inconsistencies in food quality and service across different locations, with some locations performing better than others.
NC
Nicholas Cevasco
Dec 29, 2025
5.0
Went there on a lunch date.
1.) Food was great. I hounded down my taco salad it was so good.
2.) Service was amazing. We forgot our leftovers and the server came out in the cold and wind to give them to us. 10/10 service.
MD
Maya Domingo
Dec 16, 2025
2.0
If you can, just go to the Stoneridge/Gahanna location. This particular location gives you MUCH less food for your dollar. When I order at Gahanna they give double the amount of everything. Chips, guac, cheese, you name it. Save yourself some money and opt for a different location. Disappointed in the quality control across various locations for El Vaquero. Love the Gahanna, and Riverside Drive locations.
JS
Jennifer Susi
Dec 14, 2025
5.0
Love El Vaquero in Pickerington! Food is always great and the staff are very friendly. The manager is so kind and I recommend this place to anyone!!! I usually get the carne asada tacos with rice and beans and they give great portions and everything is delicious! 😊
RD
Rachel Dixon
Dec 11, 2025
5.0
Ordered online from here tonight, it was fantastic. We had a complicated request because of an allergy and they handled it perfectly. We've been here many times and it never, ever disappoints. Staff is awesome and kind, food was amazing, highly recommend!!!
KK
Kathleen Kelley
Dec 10, 2025
5.0
I love the food. Great quality, reasonably priced. And super fast for carry out!
Frequently Asked Questions About El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant
What are the regular opening hours of El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant is open from 11:00 AM to 9:45 PM Monday through Thursday, until 10:15 PM on Friday and Saturday, and until 9:00 PM on Sunday.
What are the takeout hours available at El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
Takeout is available daily from 11:00 AM to 9:30 PM Monday through Thursday, until 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday, and until 8:45 PM on Sunday.
During what hours is delivery service offered by El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
Delivery is offered from 11:00 AM to 9:30 PM Monday through Thursday, until 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday, and until 8:45 PM on Sunday.
Does El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant offer both in-store pickup and delivery options?
Yes, El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant offers both in-store pickup and delivery services for your convenience.
Where is El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant located?
The restaurant is located at 10503 Blacklick-Eastern Rd NW Suite 100, Pickerington, OH 43217, USA.
How can I view the menu or order food from El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant online?
You can view the menu and place orders online at https://vaquerorestaurant.com/menu.
What types of cuisine and dining options does El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant offer?
El Vaquero offers Mexican cuisine including tacos, burritos, seafood, and vegetarian dishes. It also features a bar and caters for families and groups.
What nearby places can I visit for dessert after dining at El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
Nearby dessert options include Dippin' Dots ice cream shop, Humble Donut Co., and Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt, all within close proximity.
Are there beauty and wellness services near El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
Yes, nearby options include Salon Lofts Pickerington, Beauty by Miranda Griffith, Nail Essence, Ryan Shirley's hair salon, and Holly Klingerman's beauty spa.
What entertainment or fitness venues are nearby El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
You can visit Marcus Pickerington Cinema for movies or Violet City Crossfit gym for workouts, both located near the restaurant.