Donatos Pizza

Reviews

• PH

  Pamela Herb

  Feb 7, 2026
  4.0
  I would have given a perfect score but I wish they would serve diet coke again. I haven't been on the inside of a donatos since they switched.
• YI

  Yvette Isles

  Jan 11, 2026
  5.0
  This store is awesome! They have polite and friendly staff each time I've been there and the food is hot and ready when I arrive.
• ST

  Sherry Tackett

  Dec 16, 2025
  5.0
  Always Great to have when visiting Ohio
• WH

  Wes Hastings

  Dec 5, 2025
  3.0
  I come here just about every week to sit and read my book while eating my pizza. Tonight is my last visit. The service is very hit n miss. Mostly miss. I confess that I order a pizza that's not conventional, but after a whole year, I'd think that we could get things right. I wish you guys the best of luck. Wes
• FF

  Fluff

  Feb 23, 2020
  4.0
  Haven't been here since my scathing Yelp review. It's a shame. Because I enjoy a few of their specialty pizzas. But at these prices, the pizzas should ALWAYS be flawless, the service above reproach, the experience nothing short of spiritual. It is not. The pizzas are overpriced for what you get. The last time I got a sub it was as small as an airline lunch sandwich. I just got online, and almost ordered a Veggie add peppers, and a Mariachi beef add onions. Then I saw the total. $40. That was for carryout. I changed my mind and went with Grapevine. Straight pepp there, but $13 less. My God, Mr. Don. Be reasonable. UPDATE: Here's the thing: if you're an e-mail clubbie, you'll get some pretty good specials. The pizza is as good as any similar. The subs are okay. In recent history I've had few problems with this location (Pickerington). Pound for pound, you could do a lot worse. Other such pizza chains are on the decline. Donatos seems to keep chugging along.

Frequently Asked Questions About Donatos Pizza