Service quality varied significantly, with some customers praising attentive staff while others reported long wait times and inattentive service.
Food Quality
Food quality was inconsistent; while some enjoyed the wings and burgers, many complained about cold, overcooked, or poorly prepared items.
Pricing Concerns
Several customers felt that the prices were too high for the quality of food received, particularly for sides and certain menu items.
Management Response
Management was noted for being responsive to complaints, offering refunds or remakes, but some customers felt their issues were not adequately addressed.
MF
Morghan Fenstermaker
Jan 3, 2026
1.0
When we first walked in we got put in a dirty booth and needed cleaned when there was multiple other places to seat us, then we ordered a appetizer with our food witch the appetizer should’ve came out first bc it’s a APPETIZER then soon as we got the appetizer our food was right behind it not even 1min after we got our food all together, all the food wasn’t even warm like it was just sitting back there. Then we didn’t even get refills unless we showed the cup, then we asked to speak with a manager the waitress wanted to argue then when the manger came out he acted like it was a issue also but helped the issue a little bit by giving discount. The service was horrible and the food was also just bad.
CC
Crissy Cajs
Nov 25, 2025
4.0
We got to this restaurant frequently and the service is always good and the food is usually delicious .
Today (11/25/2025 @ around 7:40 was in the order was placed) we ordered a to go order, and since we had never had an issue until tonight. My daughter gives us our food (we live in Galion) and the wings are way over cooked. When my husband opened his box you could SMELL the burnt.
However, when I called the manager was very nice, understanding and offered me a refund. I declined the refund and requested to have the wings remade and we would bring back the food (minus the 1 my husband attempted to eat. No clue why he tried with the smell, but whatever)
When we got there, this blonde haired lady came out with a to go bag ready for us, she even had them remake our fries.
I gave her our old order and she apologized and was friendly!
To me the staff making it right (remaking the food) was so much better and the best possible customer service option (in my opinion)
I will come back here, not because we love the food (we do) but because the staff was super friendly and willing to acknowledge a mistake made and they made it right by remaking the food.
RV
Randy Valance
Nov 25, 2025
1.0
On Veterans day, I took it upon myself to honor myself for serving all people in our Country and came here l.
A free meal was given, but the beverage was $4.71.
I ordered the boneless wings, all Five of them lol, which were very hard and difficult to chew.
The waitress was okay, nothing to write home about.
All in all, it was a disapointent. Friends and family asked me, how was your free meal Captain?
Answering with a l, NO GO and taken as true, they are boycotting as well.
Airborne!!!
AH
Abby H
Nov 9, 2025
4.0
Depends on the day with how your service will be. Sometimes you get sat and have to wait to be acknowledged. The wings are always good and so are the drinks.
JB
Jessica Buchanan
Nov 2, 2025
1.0
This place is horrible. Our server was never to be found, our food was warm at best and my husband's wings were pitiful they were so small. They all seemed more interested in happenings with an ex-coworker than the customer. Won't be back to any Buffalo Wild Wings. Find a Wings and Rings or anything else instead!
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in Ontario, OH specialize in?
Buffalo Wild Wings specializes in award-winning Buffalo, New York-style wings with 26 sauce and seasoning options.
Where is the Buffalo Wild Wings located in Ontario, Ohio?
It is located at 949 North Lexington, Ontario, OH 44906.
What are the operating hours for Buffalo Wild Wings?
Buffalo Wild Wings is open from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM Monday through Wednesday and Sunday, and extends to 11:59 PM on Thursday through Saturday.
How can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Ontario?
You can reach them by phone at +1 419-525-2933.
Is Buffalo Wild Wings in Ontario currently open?
Yes, Buffalo Wild Wings is currently open.
What are some nearby places I can visit after dining at Buffalo Wild Wings?
Nearby places include Dunham's Sports for outdoor and sporting goods, Big Lots for discount shopping, and Stowell Park for outdoor recreation and baseball.
Are there other dining options close to Buffalo Wild Wings in Ontario?
Yes, nearby dining options include Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen for comfort food, Panda Express for Pan-Asian fast food, Wingstop for more chicken wings, and Applebee's Grill + Bar for American bar and grill fare.
Can I find mobile phone stores near Buffalo Wild Wings Ontario?
Yes, Verizon Wireless and The Cellular Connection are nearby mobile phone stores.
What recreational or active life locations are near Buffalo Wild Wings?
Stowell Park, which features a baseball field and active life opportunities, is nearby for leisure and sports activities.
Where can I shop for home improvement or furniture near Buffalo Wild Wings?
Nearby you can find Ashley, a furniture and mattress store, and Lowe's Home Improvement for various home improvement needs.