Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• UT

  Uncma the Third

  Feb 8, 2026
  1.0
  60s to 70s dollars. Very loud. No. 41. I bought a hot dog. Forgot to cook it and left just the bun on plate. WHERE IS MY FOOD? I also got a birthday cake saying HAPPY BORTHDAY LITTLE JOHNNY. My sons name is Jessica Jess Uncma the fourth. All there was was nothing but disappointment. My sons 91 st birthday ruined. I askrd for them to put barbie decorations on it. They put Mr. BEAST designs.Thank you. Have a good day. From The Bottom of The Pizza of Middletown. Inspired by the McCrackens. thanks for your creativity and innovation in pizza reviews specifically for Papa Johns. Lastly, i asked for a taco bell luxe cravings box. Nothing. Im sad.
• RS

  Rebecca Stewart

  Dec 19, 2025
  1.0
  Ordered online. Confirmation said be there 7:47, I got there at 7:50 they told me it's going to be at least 30 more minutes, staff is standing around on their phones and talking. No wonder this place had 5 people waiting in the lobby and several more in their cars. Terrible, go anywhere but here.
• BT

  Brandon Travis

  Dec 18, 2025
  1.0
  Got to the restaurant 5 mins after pizza was supposed to be ready. Was told it would be 25-30 mins. Pizza hadn’t been started yet. The employee was rude, offered no apologies, and blamed it on staffing. Will never order from this papa John’s again.
• MB

  Megan Bryant

  Dec 6, 2025
  5.0
  The twins really have this place under control, always know me by name and respectfully uses miss when addressing me everytime. I am a regular and will be as long as i'm getting this kind of service!
• JG

  Jason Gibbs

  Dec 6, 2025
  1.0
  Do yourself a favor and go get shaddocks(local) this place is trash with trashy attitudes.