Business Details
About
Pasta ShopPizza RestaurantIce Cream ShopSalad Shop
Welcome to Highland Pizza & Ice Cream!
Highland Pizza & Ice Cream has been serving locally since 1992. We have pizza,16 flavors of ice cream, subs, salads, pasta dinners and more. We specialize in delicious, homemade, Italian cuisine. Our pizzas are hand tossed and covered with the freshest ingredients in the area. Our restaurant is a bright, family-friendly, inviting eating experience!
Highland Pizza & Ice Cream is a family-owned business that has room for dining and we also do carry out and have a drive through. Everyone will find something delicious on our menu! We have an excellent staff that is here to serve all of your needs, so stop in or give us a call today!
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.4
588 reviews
5 stars
397
4 stars
100
3 stars
42
2 stars
15
1 star
34
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Customers consistently praised the pizza, subs, and ice cream for their taste and freshness, with many highlighting the generous toppings and variety of options.
Service Issues
Several reviews noted problems with order accuracy and wait times, with some customers experiencing rude interactions from staff, particularly during busy periods.
Owner Reputation
The owner received positive mentions for being friendly and involved, with many customers appreciating his long-standing presence and dedication to the community.
Atmosphere Concerns
Some customers expressed disappointment over the lack of in-house dining service and the overall condition of the dining area, indicating a decline from its previous popularity.
- BMBrandon MoodyDec 22, 20255.0I've been eating here for years, since I was a small child in the 90s. Taste hasn't changed and the owner is still rad
- SHSally HammockSep 18, 20255.0Best pizza hands down. Very generous with the toppings.
- MRMary RossSep 10, 20255.0All the bread is amazing!! The pretzel bites with nacho dip is delicious! Everything here is good. The salads are unique & made on site. Everything's fresh & staff is friendly. The Owner is a WONDERFUL human!! So Sad that the in-house seating was taken away or I would have given it a five.
- LGLaura GillespieAug 29, 20255.0Pizza and ice-cream is amazing! One of the best!
- RHRebecca HummellAug 27, 20255.0I Love the Pizza Burger try it so good ,Need Soft serve it's very good dipped not enough choices in flavors ,HOT Fudge was paste at the end of the afternoon stir it more ,but ate the paste lol The Boss needs to get you youngins more help to Stressed on them ,Love the Food very good beats driving to China TO get food ,But in all get help spand that moldy money lol Just joking but Keep it up KIDS,Tip the kids big I did .About lost our Car in the Pot HOLES IN the drive ,HOLD on .
Frequently Asked Questions About Highland Pizza & Ice Cream
What types of food does Highland Pizza & Ice Cream offer?
Highland Pizza & Ice Cream offers pizza, 16 flavors of ice cream, subs, salads, pasta dinners, and more, specializing in homemade Italian cuisine with hand tossed pizzas using fresh ingredients.
What are the operating hours of Highland Pizza & Ice Cream?
The restaurant is open Monday through Thursday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 11:30 PM, and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 10:00 PM.
Does Highland Pizza & Ice Cream offer dine-in and takeout options?
Yes, Highland Pizza & Ice Cream is a family-friendly restaurant with dining space, and also offers carry out and drive-through services.
What payment methods are accepted at Highland Pizza & Ice Cream?
The restaurant accepts cash, check, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa for payment.
Where is Highland Pizza & Ice Cream located?
It is located at 6530 State Route 229, Marengo, OH 43334, United States.
Since when has Highland Pizza & Ice Cream been serving the community?
Highland Pizza & Ice Cream has been serving the local community since 1992.
What nearby places can I visit before or after dining at Highland Pizza & Ice Cream?
Nearby you can visit Highland Community Park/Highland Sports Association for outdoor activities or The Beverly Mansion, which serves as an event and concert venue.
Are there schools near Highland Pizza & Ice Cream where students might enjoy dining here?
Yes, Highland Elementary School, Highland Middle School, and Highland High School are all nearby, making it convenient for students and families to visit the restaurant.
Which local stores can I visit near Highland Pizza & Ice Cream for additional shopping needs?
Nearby stores include Dollar General for discount shopping and Sparta General Store, which also functions as a gas station and convenience store.
How can visitors use nearby locations to reach Highland Pizza & Ice Cream easily?
Visitors can use nearby landmarks like the United States Postal Service or Highland Community Park to navigate and find the restaurant conveniently located on State Route 229 in Marengo, OH.