Voltolini's

Reviews

• CJ

  CJ Johnson

  3 days ago
  1.0
  All bad, just plain bad. Never going here again. Salads and bread arrived after sitting there for 15-20 min. Not even 2 minutes later the full order came. No time to eat salads or bread or whatever, table was completely packed of food for 4. Started to try my main plate, the Tilapia with steamed Veggies. The veggies were out of the microwave warm and raw. I asked the manager to look, and I took a baby carrot off my plate and bent it..and kept bending...eventually the thing broke and a piece flew halfway across the restaurant. I was offered a 20% discount. Umm..I only wanted what I paid for. If I wanted raw veggies I would have got them on my own, not at an upcharged restaurant. So the tilapia.. horrible. It was like someone dumped a bunch of random seasonings on it and then threw it in the deep fryer. There was no "flavorful" tilapia, it was a crust of burned seasonings on top of a few fillets. Couldnt eat it, it was horrible. If I was starving yes I would have eaten it reluctantly. But I went there with my family expecting a decent dinner. So i got a bit of a discount and ended up paying about 80 bucks. I tipped the server well bc it isnt her fault. All the food from my entire family was left on the table, minus a few bites of salad and a few bites of the other main courses, realizing it was all really bad cooking and really bad recipes. We went to walmart after and got some subs to bake in the oven. Yes I am sad and also mad that this place was so horrible. I just wanted a decent dinner tonight and this place performed in the worst possible way.
• JD

  Jason Dekker

  Jan 3, 2026
  5.0
  Great atmosphere, amazing food, and friendly staff. Food portions are large, prices are fair, and I'd definitely visit again!
• JP

  Jacquie Palazzolo

  Dec 27, 2025
  5.0
  We were visiting from Cincinnati. After spending the day hiking for 3 hours, we found this wonderful restaurant serving the best in comfort food to refuel after our hike. The staff is so friendly and especially our server, Bre! She was very attentive and make excellent suggestions. We each had a cocktail, an appetizer, and an entree. The Spin Dip is served with some delicious flat bread that is reminiscent of deep fried thin pizza crust!! The dip was yummy. Hubby had the Italian sausage with a side of spaghetti topped with marinara. He said it was good. I had the chicken carbonara and Bre recommended subbing the penne with cheese tortellini…and it was fabulous! I skipped the soup and salad and went for the garlic asparagus…again… so yummy! Everything was delicious. The atmosphere is casual and we fit right in with our hiking boots. A little pricy, but what isn’t these days?
• JP

  John Palazzolo

  Dec 27, 2025
  5.0
  Came early on a Saturday after a a day of hiking. Our server Bre was amazing!!! She offered great advice on doing the soup (not the salad as it didn’t look the best) and sub tortellini for the penne on the chicken carbonara. Great advice. The food was very good and the portions were HUGE. A little pricey for a place with such a casual atmosphere but would still highly recommend but definitely ask for Bre!!
• EA

  Edward Avery

  Nov 28, 2025
  1.0
  The empty parking lot should have been a good indicator. The empty restaurant with just the sound of people walking around and country music should’ve turned us around. But for whatever reason we decided to give it a shot. The staff is very friendly and service was quick, I’m sure due to the lack of patrons. The soup was decent but a good chunk of the salad you had to cut yourself. The calamari was ok decent but was pretty salty. And ohhhhhh boy the main dishes: I think everything was purchased at the Walmart across the street. My cheese tortellini in cheese basil came on a dish that was hot to the touch but the food itself was lukewarm at best and with cold spots. The almost $40 beef tenderloin medallions were hungry - man tv dinner quality and a fourth of the expected size. It also came with a HEAPING amount of asparagus (about six) that were wrinkled and floppy. I could go on and on about the entrees but I’ve already wasted enough time typing about this place. Although, I do believe I’m putting more effort into this review than they do the dishes. I will say the meatballs were pretty good, although the spaghetti it came with was undercooked. Heck, when they cleaned up our plates prior to giving us the check two of the servers appeared to laugh at the amount of food left on them so I’m sure the quality is well known by all staff. In summary, the food was horrible, the staff was kind, and the awkwardness of the almost dead atmosphere was all consuming. Feels like a crash grab by the Millstone people and the quality definitely backs that up. I hate that I hated it but they got my money so I know I won’t hurt any feelings. I wish I took a picture of each dish we received but we were too busy laughing at it and then sadly ate it. This restaurant was solely created for the people visiting from across the nation chasing Bigfoot in the woods. I apologize in advanced if you dine here prior to reading this review but I’m sure you got your choice of seating.

Frequently Asked Questions About Voltolini's